Disqus vs Talk

Overview

Disqus

Stacks2.5K

Followers480

Votes466

Talk

Stacks3

Followers21

Votes0

GitHub Stars2.0K

Forks363

Disqus vs Talk: What are the differences?

Disqus: Elevating the discussion, anywhere on the web. Disqus looks to make it very easy and rewarding for people to interact on websites using its system. Commenters can build reputation and carry their contributions from one website to the next; Talk: A better commenting experience from Mozilla, The New York Times, and The Washington Post. Online comments are broken. Our open-source Talk tool rethinks how moderation, comment display, and conversation function, creating the opportunity for safer, smarter discussions around your work.

Disqus and Talk can be primarily classified as "Commenting Service" tools.

Talk is an open source tool with 1.26K GitHub stars and 252 GitHub forks. Here's a link to Talk's open source repository on GitHub.

🔥 Trending in Customer Support on StackShare

Ochat Customer Support

Ochat

Try it View Docs Alternatives

Try

0

1

Advice on Disqus, Talk

Niall

Oct 5, 2020

Needs adviceon

Squarespace

Google Chrome

Safari

I created a Squarespace website with multiple blog pages. I discovered that the native Squarespace commenting tool is not currently capable of letting people subscribe to my blog pages if they are using Google Chrome or Safari! I then discovered that Disqus email verification doesn't work with Yahoo Mail. I also hate that there's no way to turn off that email verification (which I don't need since I moderate all comments anyway). So I want to use a different commenting system. I've read some good things about Commento. Three questions: (1) will it work on a Squarespace site? (I'll pay a developer to integrate it for me) (2) Does it have its own issues/elements that don't work smoothly, similar to the other two? (3) Is there another plugin I should be considering for my Squarespace site?

108k views108k

Comments

Detailed Comparison

Disqus	Talk
Disqus looks to make it very easy and rewarding for people to interact on websites using its system. Commenters can build reputation and carry their contributions from one website to the next.	Online comments are broken. Our open-source Talk tool rethinks how moderation, comment display, and conversation function, creating the opportunity for safer, smarter discussions around your work.
Clean & Intuitive- We designed the platform to be clutter-free, which keeps people's eyes focused on the discussion itself.;Fully real-time Live discussions- Discussions unfold in real-time. Comments stream as they are posted and user activity indicates life on your website.;Activity indicators- Indicators make it easier for people to notice, see, and interact with new content and activity as it happens.;Typing presence- Disqus even shows when others are in the middle of writing and editing their comment but haven’t posted just yet.;More dynamic content- The real-time system is designed for active communities, live events, and video content.;Quality discussions- A smart voting system surfaces the best content on the page.;Loyal communities- People can see your community’s unique set of top participants and other popular discussions happening across your website.;Mobile- Disqus automatically supports rich, feature-parity on phones and tablets via a fully responsive, end-to-end HTML5 design.;Recommended Conversations- Let users easily find other interesting conversations happening on your website.;Social Sharing- Allow users to easily share any comment or discussion thread to their favorite social network.;Social Reactions- Discussions around your content happens all over the web. Disqus finds these conversations from Twitter and pulls them into the discussion on your website.;Social Tagging- With @mentions, easily include others on Disqus and Twitter in your discussion. Mentioned people are notified and encouraged to join your community.;Moderation Dashboard- Our moderation panel in the Disqus admin is built for sites that have lots of commenting activity;User Reputation- Users can participate anonymously, using a pseudonym, or with a given name.;User History- Learn how long your users have been around and how active they are.;Keyboard Shortcuts- Quickly select a group of items, take action, and change tabs without touching your mouse.;In-Line & Email Moderation- Moderate your site directly on the comment thread while logged in as a moderator or moderate your comment notifications by email with three simple commands.;Spam Controls & Word Filtering- Our smart-spam system works network wide and responds to new flare-ups automatically as moderators indicate new issues.;Blacklisting & Whitelisting- With control lists, specify users, emails, IP addresses, and words.;Import and export anytime- You can import all your existing comments or export;Flexible, Powerful Partner API- Our API is full featured and allows your developers to integrate Disqus into your mobile app, widget, forum or visualization.;Analytics- Visualize data with topical trend analysis, user segmentation and ad sales packaging.;Single Sign-On- Integrate your existing login system and allow your community to comment via your proprietary sign-in, in addition to the social options Disqus makes available.;SEO Optimized- Disqus is fully indexable for search engines out- of-the-box. We have been approved by the Google Search Quality team to be organically crawled unlike any other comment platform.	-
Statistics
GitHub Stars -	GitHub Stars 2.0K
GitHub Forks -	GitHub Forks 363
Stacks 2.5K	Stacks 3
Followers 480	Followers 21
Votes 466	Votes 0
Pros & Cons
Pros 141 Ease of use 116 Free 62 Great ui 45 Sign-up not required 40 Wordpress integration Cons 4 Ads 1 Bugs with migration tool 1 Poor support	No community feedback yet
Integrations
WordPress Tumblr Blogger Squarespace	Heroku Docker

What are some alternatives to Disqus, Talk?

LiveFyre

Livefyre’s real-time apps get your audience talking and turn your site into the hub for your community. Bloggers, brands and the largest publishers in the world use Livefyre to engage their users and curate live content from around the social web.

Commento

With Commento, you wouldn't need to worry about shady ad companies getting your data through hundreds of tracking services. You wouldn't need to worry about your page being slowed down - Commento uses just 22 kB total. And it's all open source.