Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Appveyor vs Github Actions: What are the differences?
Key Differences Between Appveyor and Github Actions
Integration with Platform: Appveyor is a Continuous Integration and Deployment (CI/CD) platform that is primarily designed for Windows platforms, whereas Github Actions is a CI/CD tool integrated within the Github ecosystem, providing support for multiple platforms including Windows, MacOS, and Linux.
Supported Workflows: Appveyor is tailored specifically for building, testing, and deploying Windows-based applications, making it ideal for projects targeting the Windows platform. On the other hand, Github Actions offers a wider range of workflow possibilities, allowing developers to automate various tasks, including building, testing, and deploying applications on multiple platforms.
Ease of Use: Github Actions leverages the familiar ecosystem and interface of Github, making it easy for developers already using Github for version control to adopt and configure their workflows. Appveyor has its own separate web interface, which may require additional effort to learn and set up.
Configuration: Github Actions uses YAML-based configuration files to define workflows, giving developers fine-grained control over every aspect of their CI/CD pipelines. Appveyor also supports YAML-based configuration but also provides a web UI for configuration purposes, providing a more visual approach to defining and modifying workflows.
Integration with Version Control: Github Actions is deeply integrated with Github, allowing developers to easily trigger workflows in response to events such as code pushes, pull requests, and issue comments. Appveyor, although supporting integration with Git repositories, may require additional setup and configuration to achieve the same level of integration.
Community and Ecosystem: Github Actions benefits from being part of the Github community, which is rich in terms of resources, community contributions, and available actions shared by other users. Appveyor, while having its own community and resources, may have a smaller user base and a more specific focus on Windows-based projects.
In Summary, Appveyor is a Windows-centric CI/CD platform with a standalone web interface, while Github Actions is a more versatile, platform-agnostic CI/CD tool tightly integrated within the Github ecosystem, supporting multiple platforms and leveraging YAML-based configuration.
Pros of Appveyor
- Github integration20
- Simple, reliable & powerful18
- Hosted12
- YML-based configuration11
- Nuget support10
- Windows support6
- Free for open source4
- Automatic deployment4
- Great product, responsive people, free for open-source3
- Easy PowerShell support2
- Easy handling of secret keys2
- Remote Desktop into Build Worker1
- Advanced build workers available1
Pros of GitHub Actions
- Integration with GitHub8
- Free5
- Easy to duplicate a workflow3
- Ready actions in Marketplace3
- Configs stored in .github2
- Docker Support2
- Read actions in Marketplace2
- Active Development Roadmap1
- Fast1
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Appveyor
- Complex user interface1
- Poor documentation1
Cons of GitHub Actions
- Lacking [skip ci]5
- Lacking allow failure4
- Lacking job specific badges3
- No ssh login to servers2
- No Deployment Projects1
- No manual launch1