Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Android SDK vs Electron: What are the differences?
1. Target Platform: Android SDK is specifically designed for Android mobile devices, allowing developers to create native Android applications using Java or Kotlin programming languages. Electron, on the other hand, is a framework that enables developers to build cross-platform desktop applications using web technologies such as HTML, CSS, and JavaScript.
2. User Interface: Android applications built using the Android SDK have a native look and feel, following the design guidelines and standards of Android. Electron applications, on the other hand, can have a more customizable and flexible user interface since they can leverage HTML and CSS to create rich user interfaces.
3. Performance: Android SDK applications, being native to the Android platform, generally offer better performance compared to Electron applications. Electron applications utilize web technologies and rely on a browser engine to run, which may introduce some overhead and affect performance, especially for resource-intensive applications.
4. Development Workflow: Android SDK has a more traditional development workflow, where developers write code in Java or Kotlin, compile it into bytecode, and package it as an Android application. Electron, on the other hand, follows a web development workflow, allowing developers to use familiar web technologies and frameworks, making it easier to prototype and develop applications quickly.
5. Deployment: Android applications built using the Android SDK are typically distributed through the Google Play Store or other Android app stores. Electron applications can be distributed as standalone executables for different operating systems, making it easier to distribute and install them on users' devices without the need for an app store.
6. Access to Device Features: Android SDK provides extensive access to various device features and APIs, allowing developers to build applications that interact closely with the hardware and software capabilities of Android devices. Electron, since it is built using web technologies, may have limitations in terms of direct access to certain device features, requiring additional workarounds or the use of native modules.
In Summary, Android SDK is focused on native Android development with a strong emphasis on performance and direct hardware/software access, while Electron enables cross-platform desktop application development using web technologies, with a more flexible user interface and deployment options.
We actually initially wrote a lot of networking code in Kotlin but the complexities involved prompted us to try and compile NodeJS for Android and port over all the networking logic to Node and communicate with node over the Java Native Interface.
This turned out to be a great decision considering our battery usage fell by 40% and rate of development increased by a factor of 2.
Pros of Android SDK
- Android development289
- Necessary for android155
- Android studio128
- Mobile framework86
- Backed by google82
- Platform-tools27
- Eclipse + adt plugin21
- Powerful, simple, one stop environment5
- Free3
- Больно3
Pros of Electron
- Easy to make rich cross platform desktop applications69
- Open source53
- Great looking apps such as Slack and Visual Studio Code14
- Because it's cross platform8
- Use Node.js in the Main Process4
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Android SDK
Cons of Electron
- Uses a lot of memory18
- User experience never as good as a native app8
- No proper documentation4
- Does not native4
- Each app needs to install a new chromium + nodejs1
- Wrong reference for dom inspection1