Material Design vs Topcoat

Overview

Topcoat

Stacks3

Followers13

Votes15

GitHub Stars4.2K

Forks368

Material Design

Stacks594

Followers890

Votes14

Material Design vs Topcoat: What are the differences?

Developers describe Material Design as "Google's Material Design". Material Design is a unified system that combines theory, resources, and tools for crafting digital experiences. On the other hand, Topcoat is detailed as "CSS for clean and fast web apps". TopCoat is made up of base controls, platform specific styles, themes and a build script to stitch them all together.

Material Design and Topcoat can be primarily classified as "Front-End Frameworks" tools.

"They really set a new bar in design" is the primary reason why developers consider Material Design over the competitors, whereas "Open source" was stated as the key factor in picking Topcoat.

Topcoat is an open source tool with 4.31K GitHub stars and 417 GitHub forks. Here's a link to Topcoat's open source repository on GitHub.

Share your Stack

Help developers discover the tools you use. Get visibility for your team's tech choices and contribute to the community's knowledge.

View Docs

CLI (Node.js)

Manual

Advice on Topcoat, Material Design

Ashish

Sr. UI Associate at Daffodil Software

Dec 29, 2020

Needs adviceon

Bootstrap

Material Design

Tailwind CSS

I am a bit confused when to choose Bootstrap vs Material Design or Tailwind CSS, and why? I mean, in which kind of projects we can work with bootstrap/Material/Tailwind CSS? If the design is made up on the grid, we prefer bootstrap, and if flat design, then material design. Similarly, when do we choose tailwind CSS?

Any suggestion would be appreciated?

735k views735k

Comments

Raj

Jan 3, 2021

Review

Hi Ashish,

If you need minimal work to be done from your end and like most of the components / design available out of the box - go with Bootstrap. This is the oldest and has the widest adoption and a whole range of components built out by others.

If you like Material design, this is a good choice too. Please note that Bootstrap also has a Material theme, though it is not as native.

Both of these above frameworks are bulky and has more than what you may need.

If you like to build micro-components in a elegant way, TailwindCSS is the way to go.

307k views307k

Comments

Ryan

Mar 11, 2021

Decided

Ant Design offers the most components with JS and CSS taken care of. They look clean, professional, and usable.

We paired this with Bulma for making the containers and structure reactive. Bulma (for react) make it easy to just add a section, container, and content and have it work on all platforms.

We also use Geist UI, though not recognized by Stack share, for its simple and modern feel. Highly recommend Geist if you want modern components for complicated UI's

220k views220k

Comments

Detailed Comparison

Topcoat	Material Design
TopCoat is made up of base controls, platform specific styles, themes and a build script to stitch them all together.	Material Design is a unified system that combines theory, resources, and tools for crafting digital experiences.
Components Galore; Themeable;BEM Architecture;Even our font is open source;Icons how you want them;PSD included;Available via CDN	-
Statistics
GitHub Stars 4.2K	GitHub Stars -
GitHub Forks 368	GitHub Forks -
Stacks 3	Stacks 594
Followers 13	Followers 890
Votes 15	Votes 14
Pros & Cons
Pros 3 Backed by Adobe 3 Open source 2 Themeable 2 Pretty 1 Lightweight	Pros 5 They really set a new bar in design 4 An intuitive design 3 Simply, And Beautiful 2 Many great libraries 0 Composants Cons 2 Sometimes, it can hang the browser

What are some alternatives to Topcoat, Material Design?

Bootstrap

Bootstrap is the most popular HTML, CSS, and JS framework for developing responsive, mobile first projects on the web.

Foundation

Foundation is the most advanced responsive front-end framework in the world. You can quickly prototype and build sites or apps that work on any kind of device with Foundation, which includes layout constructs (like a fully responsive grid), elements and best practices.

Semantic UI

Semantic empowers designers and developers by creating a shared vocabulary for UI.

Materialize

A CSS Framework based on material design.

Material Design for Angular

Material Design is a specification for a unified system of visual, motion, and interaction design that adapts across different devices. Our goal is to deliver a lean, lightweight set of AngularJS-native UI elements that implement the material design system for use in Angular SPAs.

Material-UI

Material UI is a library of React UI components that implements Google's Material Design.

Blazor

Blazor is a .NET web framework that runs in any browser. You author Blazor apps using C#/Razor and HTML.

Quasar Framework

Build responsive Single Page Apps, SSR Apps, PWAs, Hybrid Mobile Apps and Electron Apps, all using the same codebase!, powered with Vue.

Nuxt.js

Nuxt.js presets all the configuration needed to make your development of a Vue.js application enjoyable. You can use Nuxt.js for SSR, SPA, Static Generated, PWA and more.

UIkIt

UIkit gives you a comprehensive collection of HTML, CSS, and JS components which is simple to use, easy to customize and extendable.

Related Comparisons

Topcoat is an open source tool with 4.31K GitHub stars and 417 GitHub forks. Here's a link to Topcoat's open source repository on GitHub.

Material Design vs Topcoat