AWS IAM vs BeyondTrust

Overview

AWS IAM

Stacks1.2K

Followers819

Votes26

BeyondTrust

Stacks10

Followers19

Votes0

AWS IAM vs BeyondTrust: What are the differences?

Key Differences between AWS IAM and BeyondTrust

AWS IAM and BeyondTrust are both systems that provide identity and access management (IAM) solutions. However, there are several significant differences between the two platforms:

Architecture: AWS IAM is a cloud-based service offered by Amazon Web Services, while BeyondTrust is an on-premise solution. This difference in architecture means that AWS IAM can be easily accessed and managed remotely, while BeyondTrust requires physical installation and management within the organization's infrastructure.
Scalability: AWS IAM is highly scalable and can be easily adjusted to accommodate the needs of organizations of any size. It can handle millions of users and access policies without any loss in performance. On the other hand, BeyondTrust may face limitations in scalability, as it relies on the organization's infrastructure for resources.
Integration: AWS IAM is deeply integrated with the entire AWS ecosystem, providing seamless access control for various AWS services and resources. BeyondTrust, on the other hand, is designed to integrate with a wide range of on-premise applications and systems, making it suitable for organizations that have a diverse IT infrastructure.
Availability: With AWS IAM being a cloud service, it offers high availability and redundancy built into the platform. By leveraging Amazon's global infrastructure, AWS IAM ensures that the service is always accessible and reliable. BeyondTrust, being an on-premise solution, may rely on the organization's infrastructure for availability and redundancy, which could be subject to potential failures.
Cost Structure: AWS IAM follows a pay-as-you-go pricing model, where users are billed based on their actual usage. This offers organizations flexibility in managing their IAM costs according to their specific needs. Alternatively, BeyondTrust typically involves upfront costs for licenses, hardware, and ongoing maintenance, which may be less flexible for smaller organizations.
Managed Services: AWS IAM is a fully managed service, meaning that Amazon takes care of the maintenance, updates, and security of the platform. This frees up the organization's IT resources and allows them to focus on other critical tasks. BeyondTrust requires the organization to maintain and manage the solution themselves, which could involve additional time, effort, and expertise.

In Summary, AWS IAM and BeyondTrust differ in their architecture, scalability, integration capabilities, availability, cost structure, and managed services. While AWS IAM is a cloud-based, scalable, and fully managed service tightly integrated with the AWS ecosystem, BeyondTrust is an on-premise solution with broader integration capabilities but potentially limited scalability and availability.

Share your Stack

Help developers discover the tools you use. Get visibility for your team's tech choices and contribute to the community's knowledge.

View Docs

CLI (Node.js)

Manual

Detailed Comparison

AWS IAM	BeyondTrust
It enables you to manage access to AWS services and resources securely. Using IAM, you can create and manage AWS users and groups, and use permissions to allow and deny their access to AWS resources.	It supports a family of privileged identity management, privileged remote access, and vulnerability management products for UNIX, Linux, Windows and Mac OS operating systems.
Manage IAM users and their access - You can create users in IAM, assign them individual security credentials (i.e., access keys, passwords, and Multi-Factor Authentication devices) or request temporary security credentials to provide users access to AWS services and resources.;Manage IAM roles and their permissions - You can create roles in IAM, and manage permissions to control which operations can be performed by the entity, or AWS service, that assumes the role. You can also define which entity is allowed to assume the role.;Manage federated users and their permissions - You can enable identity federation to allow existing identities (e.g. users) from your corporate directory or from a 3rd party such as Login with Amazon, Facebook, and Google to access the AWS Management Console, to call AWS APIs, and to access resources, without the need to create an IAM user for each identity.	Universal Privilege Management; More Than Just Passwords; Frictionless experience for users; Handle critical tasks that keep your business running
Statistics
Stacks 1.2K	Stacks 10
Followers 819	Followers 19
Votes 26	Votes 0
Pros & Cons
Pros 23 Centralized powerful permissions based access 3 Straightforward SSO integration Cons 1 No equivalent for on-premise networks, must adapt to AD 1 Cloud auth limited to resources, no apps or services	No community feedback yet
Integrations
No integrations available	Linux macOS Windows

What are some alternatives to AWS IAM, BeyondTrust?

Identity Management Simplified

Keycloak Enterprise-grade identity & access management, fully managed! Enable user authentication and authorization in minutes, so you can keep growing.

Teleport

Teleport makes it easy for users to securely access infrastructure and meet the toughest compliance requirements. Teleport replaces shared credentials with short-lived certificates and is completely transparent to client-side tools.

SailPoint

It provides enterprise identity governance solutions with on-premises and cloud-based identity management software for the most complex challenges.

HashiCorp Boundary

Simple and secure remote access — to any system anywhere based on trusted identity. It enables practitioners and operators to securely access dynamic hosts and services with fine-grained authorization without requiring direct network access.

AWS Service Catalog

AWS Service Catalog allows IT administrators to create, manage, and distribute catalogs of approved products to end users, who can then access the products they need in a personalized portal. Administrators can control which users have access to each application or AWS resource to enforce compliance with organizational business policies. AWS Service Catalog allows your organization to benefit from increased agility and reduced costs because end users can find and launch only the products they need from a catalog that you control.

Infra

It enables you to discover and access infrastructure (e.g. Kubernetes, databases). We help you connect an identity provider such as Okta or Azure active directory, and map users/groups with the permissions you set to your infrastructure.

Oathkeeper

A cloud native Identity & Access Proxy (IAP) which authenticates and authorizes incoming HTTP requests. Inspired by the BeyondCorp / Zero Trust white paper. Written in Go.

Key Vault Access Policy

It determines whether a given service principal, namely an application or user group, can perform different operations on Key Vault secrets, keys, and certificates. You can assign access policies using the Azure portal, the Azure CLI, or Azure PowerShell.

GCP IAM

It lets you create and manage permissions for Google Cloud resources. IAM unifies access control for Google Cloud services into a single system and presents a consistent set of operations.

Thycotic Secret Server

It is an enterprise-grade, privileged access management solution that is quickly deployable and easily managed. You can automatically discover and manage your privileged accounts through an intuitive interface, protecting against malicious activity, enterprise-wide.

Related Comparisons

AWS IAM vs BeyondTrust: What are the differences?

Key Differences between AWS IAM and BeyondTrust

AWS IAM and BeyondTrust are both systems that provide identity and access management (IAM) solutions. However, there are several significant differences between the two platforms:

Architecture: AWS IAM is a cloud-based service offered by Amazon Web Services, while BeyondTrust is an on-premise solution. This difference in architecture means that AWS IAM can be easily accessed and managed remotely, while BeyondTrust requires physical installation and management within the organization's infrastructure.
Scalability: AWS IAM is highly scalable and can be easily adjusted to accommodate the needs of organizations of any size. It can handle millions of users and access policies without any loss in performance. On the other hand, BeyondTrust may face limitations in scalability, as it relies on the organization's infrastructure for resources.
Integration: AWS IAM is deeply integrated with the entire AWS ecosystem, providing seamless access control for various AWS services and resources. BeyondTrust, on the other hand, is designed to integrate with a wide range of on-premise applications and systems, making it suitable for organizations that have a diverse IT infrastructure.
Availability: With AWS IAM being a cloud service, it offers high availability and redundancy built into the platform. By leveraging Amazon's global infrastructure, AWS IAM ensures that the service is always accessible and reliable. BeyondTrust, being an on-premise solution, may rely on the organization's infrastructure for availability and redundancy, which could be subject to potential failures.
Cost Structure: AWS IAM follows a pay-as-you-go pricing model, where users are billed based on their actual usage. This offers organizations flexibility in managing their IAM costs according to their specific needs. Alternatively, BeyondTrust typically involves upfront costs for licenses, hardware, and ongoing maintenance, which may be less flexible for smaller organizations.
Managed Services: AWS IAM is a fully managed service, meaning that Amazon takes care of the maintenance, updates, and security of the platform. This frees up the organization's IT resources and allows them to focus on other critical tasks. BeyondTrust requires the organization to maintain and manage the solution themselves, which could involve additional time, effort, and expertise.

AWS IAM vs BeyondTrust

Overview

AWS IAM vs BeyondTrust: What are the differences?