Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
ArcGIS vs Google Maps: What are the differences?
ArcGIS is a robust geospatial platform for professionals, while Google Maps is a user-friendly web mapping service designed for easy navigation and business discovery. Let's explore the key differences between the two:
Map Development: ArcGIS is primarily a geographic information system (GIS) software used for creating, analyzing, and sharing spatial data. It offers extensive data manipulation and advanced analysis capabilities. On the other hand, Google Maps is a web-based mapping platform focused on providing user-friendly mapping services for navigation and location-based searches. It emphasizes ease of use and simplicity for the user.
Data Sources: ArcGIS allows users to work with a wide variety of data sources, including proprietary datasets, government data, and specialized GIS data formats. It offers advanced tools for data management and geoprocessing. In contrast, Google Maps relies heavily on its own data infrastructure, which includes its street view imagery, satellite imagery, and 3D mapping data. While it provides access to some public data sources, Google Maps has limited support for working with other data formats.
Customization: ArcGIS enables developers to customize and extend its functionality using its comprehensive set of APIs and SDKs. It provides a wide range of tools and libraries for building custom applications, integrating with other systems, and creating custom workflows. Google Maps, on the other hand, offers a more limited set of customization options. While it provides JavaScript APIs for embedding maps and adding overlays and markers, the customization capabilities are more focused on styling and user interaction rather than deep customization of functionality.
Offline Capabilities: ArcGIS provides robust offline capabilities, allowing users to work with their maps even when there is no internet connectivity. It offers tools for caching and preloading data, as well as offline editing and synchronization capabilities. Google Maps, however, relies heavily on an internet connection for most of its features. While it offers some limited offline functionality, such as caching maps for a specific area, the offline capabilities are not as extensive as those provided by ArcGIS.
Collaboration and Sharing: ArcGIS emphasizes collaboration and sharing of spatial data across organizations and stakeholders. It offers features for sharing maps, apps, and data with individuals or groups, both within and outside of an organization. Google Maps, on the other hand, is more focused on providing a seamless and consistent user experience for individual users. While it allows users to share locations and directions with others, the collaboration features are not as robust as those of ArcGIS.
Pricing and Licensing: ArcGIS is a commercial software product that requires a license for full access to all its features. It offers different licensing options for individuals, organizations, and developers. Google Maps, on the other hand, provides a free tier for basic usage, but also offers pricing plans for higher usage levels and advanced features. The pricing model for Google Maps is primarily based on the number of map views or usage.
In summary, ArcGIS is a highly capable GIS software with advanced data manipulation, analysis, and customization features, suitable for organizations and developers working with spatial data. Google Maps, on the other hand, is a user-friendly mapping platform focused on providing navigation and location-based services, with a simpler customization framework and a strong emphasis on ease of use.
From a StackShare Community member: "We're a team of two starting to write a mobile app. The app will heavily rely on maps and this is where my partner and I are not seeing eye-to-eye. I would like to go with an open source solution like OpenStreetMap that is used by Apple & Foursquare. He would like to go with Google Maps since more apps use it and has better support (according to him). Mapbox is also an option but I don’t know much about it."
I use Mapbox because We need 3D maps and navigation, it has a great plugin for React and React Native which we use. Also the Mapbox Geocoder is great.
Google Maps is best because it is practically free (they give you $300 in free credits per month and it's really hard to go over the free tier unless you really mean business) and it's the best!
I use OpenStreetMap because that has a strong community. It takes some time to catch up with Google Maps, but OpenStreetMap will become great solution.
I use Google Maps because it has a lot of great features such as Google's rich APIs, geolocation functions, navigation search feature, street map view, auto-generated 3D city map.
I use OpenStreetMap because i have the control of the environment, using Docker containers or bare-metal servers.
Pros of ArcGIS
- Reponsive7
- A lot of widgets4
- Data driven vizualisation4
- Easy tà learn2
- 3D2
- Easy API1
Pros of Google Maps
- Free253
- Address input through maps api136
- Sharable Directions81
- Google Earth47
- Unique46
- Custom maps designing3
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of ArcGIS
Cons of Google Maps
- Google Attributions and logo4
- Only map allowed alongside google place autocomplete1