Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
C vs Vala: What are the differences?
What is C? One of the most widely used programming languages of all time. .
What is Vala? An object-oriented programming language. It is a programming language using modern high level abstractions without imposing additional runtime requirements and without using a different ABI compared to applications and libraries written in C.
C and Vala can be primarily classified as "Languages" tools.
As a personal research project I wanted to add post-quantum crypto KEM (key encapsulation) algorithms and new symmetric crypto session algorithms to openssh. I found the openssh code and its channel/context management extremely complex.
Concurrently, I was learning Go. It occurred to me that Go's excellent standard library, including crypto libraries, plus its much safer memory model and string/buffer handling would be better suited to a secure remote shell solution. So I started from scratch, writing a clean-room Go-based solution, without regard for ssh compatibility. Interactive and token-based login, secure copy and tunnels.
Of course, it needs a proper security audit for side channel attacks, protocol vulnerabilities and so on -- but I was impressed by how much simpler a client-server application with crypto and complex terminal handling was in Go.
$ sloc openssh-portable Languages Files Code Comment Blank Total CodeLns Total 502 112982 14327 15705 143014 100.0% C 389 105938 13349 14416 133703 93.5% Shell 92 6118 937 1129 8184 5.7% Make 16 468 37 131 636 0.4% AWK 1 363 0 7 370 0.3% C++ 3 79 4 18 101 0.1% Conf 1 16 0 4 20 0.0% $ sloc xs Languages Files Code Comment Blank Total CodeLns Total 34 3658 1231 655 5544 100.0% Go 19 3230 1199 507 4936 89.0% Markdown 2 181 0 76 257 4.6% Make 7 148 4 50 202 3.6% YAML 1 39 0 5 44 0.8% Text 1 30 0 7 37 0.7% Modula 1 16 0 2 18 0.3% Shell 3 14 28 8 50 0.9%
Pros of C lang
- Performance69
- Low-level49
- Portability36
- Hardware level29
- Embedded apps19
- Pure13
- Performance of assembler9
- Ubiquity8
- Great for embedded6
- Old4
- Compiles quickly4
- No garbage collection to slow it down3
- OpenMP2
- Gnu/linux interoperable2
Pros of Vala
- Fast as C1
- Easy sintax simular to C#/Java with sugar from Pyrthon1
- Much easier to do Concurrent/Parallel vs C/C++1
- Productive1
- ARC instead of GC, which is able not only to delete obj1
- The only lang that allows you to create safe OOP wraps1
- With GIR/SWIG u can call vala from any lang1
- Easy learning curve if you're coming from C lang1
- Very documented. valadoc.org1
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of C lang
- Low-level5
- No built in support for parallelism (e.g. map-reduce)3
- Lack of type safety3
- No built in support for concurrency3