Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

Flat UI

103
135
+ 1
0
Material-UI

1.8K
3.1K
+ 1
389
Semantic UI

871
1.5K
+ 1
673
Advice on Flat UI, Material-UI, and Semantic UI
Needs advice
on
reactstrapreactstrap
and
Material-UIMaterial-UI

My React website is a simple 5-pager that attaches to a database to store and display registrations and other data. The user (small user base) can change any form elements, but I don't need theme-ing, though that would be fun for the user. reactstrap/react-bootstrap built on Bootstrap 4 sounds dated. I am familiar with reactstrap, but a friend said to try Material-UI. The thought of learning it is interesting, but somehow I think it might be overkill. So... reactstrap, react-bootstrap, or Material UI, which should I use?

See more
Replies (8)

MaterialUI may be overkill for such a simple project, you're right. So I'm recommending both tools in this StackShare form.

But if it's planned to increase the project, consider migrating it to MUI in advance. Among its pros I can name: - brilliant TS support - all popular use cases covered - well documented - backed by sponsors == will live and be maintained

See more
Recommends
Material-UIMaterial-UI

I recommend Material-UI for a couple reasons. 1. It’s very easy to throw MUI into React. You can essentially just import the components you need in place of yours. Effectively, for a button, for example, you can swap out <button for MUI’s <Button and you can be done if that’s all you want. Looks great, no hassle, and they have simple guides to help you make good UI decisions on top of that. 2. It’s pretty up-to-date, and it has great docs. I use MUI all the time, and if I were doing a simple, small user-base app, I would definitely use it for the sake of convenience and speed of development.

See more
Robert Smith
Tech Delivery Manager at self · | 2 upvotes · 17.4K views
Recommends

I've used material UI and had great success with it on React projects. Semantic UI is also another great option https://semantic-ui.com/.

When you say its "overkill", I would think long term. I do a lot of small projects not only for the purpose of the project, but also for learning, future projects and to use professionaly. It's a long-term investment.

See more
Recommends

It's totally the design decision if you like to follow bootstrap design then you should go for reactstrap. But if you want to follow google material design then you should go for material ui.

See more
Flavio Ribeiro
REACT DEVELOPER at Beblue · | 1 upvotes · 17.4K views
Recommends
Material-UIMaterial-UI

Material-UI is the good choice for a small project. It's fast for development, maintenance, and is ready to use. It HaveMaterial-UI is the good choice for a small project. It's fast for development, maintenance, and is ready to use. Has an excellent documentation with pratic examples.

See more
Recommends
Material-UIMaterial-UI

Much more modern in terms on support for css in js. But go for v5 not v4 as material-ui is going through a transition in term of its own implementation

See more
Malik Bagwala
Front-end Developer at Vesatogo Innovations · | 1 upvotes · 17.5K views
Recommends
Chakra UIChakra UI

Chakra UI seems like the perfect fit in my opinion. It has a much powerful design system, all the necessary components and it is dead simple to learn. And pretty easy to customize too.

See more
Recommends
Material-UIMaterial-UI

Material-UI looks great and is easy to use. Highly recommended, my favourite UI framework for React.

See more
Needs advice
on
Next.jsNext.jsMaterial-UIMaterial-UI
and
Ant DesignAnt Design

Hi, I start building an admin dashboard with next.js and looking for a frontend framework ( components ready ). So I end up with Ant Design and Material-UI, but I never built a project with these two.

Here is a list of my requirements.

  1. Good documentation.
  2. easy CRUD ( date picker and date range picker bundled )
  3. built-in multi-lang feature or Great 3rd library support
  4. Admin dashboard template
  5. well code maintenance

Which is better for the long run?

See more
Replies (2)
Recommends

I'm using both of them. But If you want to create admin dashboard, You should try AntDesign. They (Alibaba / Taobao) created a group of UI libaries to create admin dashboard. It's production ready. https://procomponents.ant.design/en-US/components/table https://pro.ant.design/docs/layout In my opinion, If you want to create a dashboard with mobile first / simple dashboard, you can choice material ui. otherwise, antdesign is better (if you want focus on desktop /tablet ui). Some of skeleton has built with material ui such as react-admin is good point to start. But if you want to create admin site with antdesign, I think you should build with umijs (it is alternative and compatible with nextjs and antd support directlly)

See more
Irving Caamal
Full Stack Developer at Freelance · | 2 upvotes · 64.3K views
Recommends

https://github.com/uber/baseweb I highly recommend you baseweb, it's easy and very customizable and also beautiful.

See more
Decisions about Flat UI, Material-UI, and Semantic UI
Kexin Lin
at University of Toronto · | 8 upvotes · 161.7K views

I replaced Bootstrap with Material-UI during the front-end UI development, because Material-UI adopts a component-based importing style, making it suit well in a "React programming style". This makes me comfortable when programming because I can treat importing UI components as other React components I define.

See more
Xinyi Liu
Software Developer at BigClarity · | 6 upvotes · 225.4K views

As our team will be building a web application, HTML5 and CSS3 are one of the standardized combinations to implement the structure and the styling of a webpage. Material-UI comes with all sorts of predesigned web components such as buttons and dropdowns that will save us tons of development time. Since it is a component library designed for React, it suits our needs. However, we do acknowledge that predesigned components may sometimes cause pains especially when it comes to custom styling. To make our life even easier, we also adopted Tailwind CSS. It is a CSS framework providing low-level utility classes that will act as building blocks when we create custom designs.

See more

Fonts and typography are fun. Material Design is a framework (developed by Google) that basically geeks out on how to assemble your typographical elements together into a design language. If you're into fonts and typography, it's fantastic. It provides a theming engine, reusable components, and can pull different user interfaces together under a common design paradigm. I'd highly recommend looking into Borries Schwesinger's book "The Form Book" if you're going to be working with Material UI or are otherwise new to component design.

https://www.amazon.com/Form-Book-Creating-Printed-Online/dp/0500515085

See more
Get Advice from developers at your company using Private StackShare. Sign up for Private StackShare.
Learn More
Pros of Flat UI
Pros of Material-UI
Pros of Semantic UI
    Be the first to leave a pro
    • 122
      React
    • 77
      Material Design
    • 53
      Ui components
    • 26
      CSS framework
    • 21
      Component
    • 12
      Looks great
    • 10
      Responsive
    • 10
      Good documentation
    • 9
      LESS
    • 7
      Open source
    • 6
      Code examples
    • 5
      Flexible
    • 5
      Ui component
    • 4
      JSS
    • 3
      Supports old browsers out of the box
    • 3
      Angular
    • 3
      Fun
    • 3
      Very accessible
    • 2
      Designed for Server Side Rendering
    • 2
      LADO
    • 2
      Barev Arman
    • 2
      Interface
    • 1
      Easy to work with
    • 1
      Asdasd
    • 0
      555
    • 0
      User
    • 157
      Easy to use and looks elegant
    • 92
      Variety of components
    • 64
      Themes
    • 61
      Has out-of-the-box widgets i would actually use
    • 57
      Semantic, duh
    • 44
      Its the future
    • 42
      Open source
    • 37
      Very active development
    • 31
      Far less complicated structure
    • 28
      Gulp
    • 9
      Already has more features than bootstrap
    • 8
      Just compare it to Bootstrap and you'll be hooked
    • 7
      UI components
    • 7
      Clean and consistent markup model
    • 6
      Responsiveness
    • 4
      Elegant. clean. readable. maintainable
    • 4
      Because it is semantic :-D
    • 4
      Good-Looking
    • 2
      Great docs
    • 2
      Consistent
    • 2
      Is big and look really great, nothing like this
    • 2
      Modular and scalable
    • 1
      Jquery
    • 1
      Easy to use
    • 1
      Blends with reactjs

    Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions

    Cons of Flat UI
    Cons of Material-UI
    Cons of Semantic UI
      Be the first to leave a con
      • 29
        Hard to learn. Bad documentation
      • 23
        Hard to customize
      • 19
        Hard to understand Docs
      • 6
        Extra library needed for date/time pickers
      • 6
        Bad performance
      • 5
        Long Code
      • 5
        For editable table component need to use material-table
      • 5
        Outdated build tool (gulp 3))
      • 3
        Poor accessibility support
      • 3
        HTML is not semantic (see list component)
      • 2
        Javascript is tied to jquery

      Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions

      - No public GitHub repository available -

      What is Flat UI?

      Flat UI is a beautiful theme for Bootstrap. We have redesigned many of its components to look flat in every pixel.

      What is Material-UI?

      MUI (formerly Material-UI) is the React UI library you always wanted. Follow your own design system, or start with Material Design.

      What is Semantic UI?

      Semantic empowers designers and developers by creating a shared vocabulary for UI.

      Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

      What companies use Flat UI?
      What companies use Material-UI?
      What companies use Semantic UI?

      Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions

      What tools integrate with Flat UI?
      What tools integrate with Material-UI?
      What tools integrate with Semantic UI?

      Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions

      What are some alternatives to Flat UI, Material-UI, and Semantic UI?
      Material Design
      Material Design is a unified system that combines theory, resources, and tools for crafting digital experiences.
      Bootstrap
      Bootstrap is the most popular HTML, CSS, and JS framework for developing responsive, mobile first projects on the web.
      Animate.css
      It is a bunch of cool, fun, and cross-browser animations for you to use in your projects. Great for emphasis, home pages, sliders, and general just-add-water-awesomeness.
      Material Design for Angular
      Material Design is a specification for a unified system of visual, motion, and interaction design that adapts across different devices. Our goal is to deliver a lean, lightweight set of AngularJS-native UI elements that implement the material design system for use in Angular SPAs.
      Tailwind CSS
      Tailwind is different from frameworks like Bootstrap, Foundation, or Bulma in that it's not a UI kit. It doesn't have a default theme, and there are no build-in UI components. It comes with a menu of predesigned widgets to build your site with, but doesn't impose design decisions that are difficult to undo.
      See all alternatives