Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Material-UI vs React Spectrum: What are the differences?
Introduction
This Markdown code provides a comparison of the key differences between Material-UI and React Spectrum, two popular UI libraries used with React.
Design Philosophy: Material-UI follows the Material Design guidelines by Google, focusing on creating visually appealing and interactive UI components. React Spectrum, on the other hand, aims for a more accessible and inclusive design system, following the Adobe Spectrum Design System.
Component Set: Material-UI offers a comprehensive set of pre-styled and ready-to-use UI components, covering a wide range of use cases. React Spectrum provides a smaller set of components, but they are highly customizable and modular, allowing developers to build their own specific components more easily.
Styling Approach: Material-UI provides a styling solution called JSS (JavaScript Style Sheets), which allows styling components using JavaScript objects. React Spectrum uses CSS-in-JS approach and provides support for CSS modules and CSS variables, allowing developers to leverage more traditional CSS syntax.
Component Theming: Material-UI includes built-in theming support, allowing developers to easily customize the look and feel of their components. React Spectrum also supports theming but takes a more flexible approach, where components can adapt to the parent theme or have their own specific themes.
Component Accessibility: Material-UI puts a strong emphasis on accessibility, with many components following the WCAG standards. React Spectrum also prioritizes accessibility, but it includes additional features such as automatic keyboard focus management and ARIA attribute support to enhance accessibility.
Community and Ecosystem: Material-UI has a large and active community with extensive documentation, support, and a wide range of third-party integrations and resources available. React Spectrum, being a newer library, has a growing community and ecosystem, but may have a smaller number of resources and integrations compared to Material-UI.
In Summary, Material-UI offers a comprehensive set of pre-styled components with a focus on Material Design, while React Spectrum provides a smaller but highly customizable component set with a more inclusive design approach.
Fonts and typography are fun. Material Design is a framework (developed by Google) that basically geeks out on how to assemble your typographical elements together into a design language. If you're into fonts and typography, it's fantastic. It provides a theming engine, reusable components, and can pull different user interfaces together under a common design paradigm. I'd highly recommend looking into Borries Schwesinger's book "The Form Book" if you're going to be working with Material UI or are otherwise new to component design.
https://www.amazon.com/Form-Book-Creating-Printed-Online/dp/0500515085
Pros of Material-UI
- React141
- Material Design82
- Ui components60
- CSS framework30
- Component26
- Looks great15
- Responsive13
- Good documentation12
- LESS9
- Ui component8
- Open source7
- Flexible6
- Code examples6
- JSS5
- Supports old browsers out of the box3
- Interface3
- Angular3
- Very accessible3
- Fun3
- Typescript support2
- # of components2
- Designed for Server Side Rendering2
- Support for multiple styling systems1
- Accessibility1
- Easy to work with1
- Css1
Pros of React Spectrum
- Consistant UI1
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Material-UI
- Hard to learn. Bad documentation36
- Hard to customize29
- Hard to understand Docs22
- Bad performance9
- Extra library needed for date/time pickers7
- For editable table component need to use material-table7
- Typescript Support2
- # of components1