Beanstalkd vs Sidekiq vs delayed_job

Overview

Sidekiq

Stacks1.2K

Followers632

Votes408

Beanstalkd

Stacks111

Followers161

Votes74

delayed_job

Stacks53

Followers65

Votes6

GitHub Stars4.8K

Forks952

Beanstalkd vs Sidekiq vs delayed_job: What are the differences?

Introduction:

Beanstalkd, Sidekiq, and delayed_job are all popular background processing systems used in web development to handle tasks asynchronously.

Architecture: Beanstalkd is a simple, fast work queue service, while Sidekiq is a Ruby-based background processing system designed to be simple and efficient. On the other hand, delayed_job is a Ruby gem for queueing jobs and deferred execution.
Dependencies: Beanstalkd does not have any dependencies. Sidekiq requires Redis as a backend for job storage and processing. delayed_job relies on Active Record and a database table for storing job information.
Concurrency: Sidekiq's multi-threaded approach allows it to process multiple jobs concurrently using a small number of threads. Beanstalkd, however, relies on multiple worker processes to handle concurrency. delayed_job operates in a single-threaded manner, processing jobs sequentially.
Monitoring: Beanstalkd provides basic monitoring and stats through telnet commands. Sidekiq offers a web interface for monitoring and managing jobs, providing real-time statistics. delayed_job lacks a built-in monitoring tool but can be integrated with external monitoring services.
Error Handling: Sidekiq provides robust error handling and automatic retry mechanisms for failed jobs. Beanstalkd offers basic error logging but lacks built-in retry functionality. delayed_job requires manual intervention for handling errors and retries.
Community Support: Sidekiq has a large and active community, with extensive documentation and support available. Beanstalkd also has a dedicated user base, but may not offer as much support as Sidekiq. delayed_job, being a part of the Rails ecosystem, benefits from the Rails community's support but may not have as much standalone support.

In Summary, Beanstalkd, Sidekiq, and delayed_job each have unique features and characteristics that make them suitable for different types of background processing tasks in web development.

Share your Stack

Help developers discover the tools you use. Get visibility for your team's tech choices and contribute to the community's knowledge.

View Docs

CLI (Node.js)

Manual

Detailed Comparison

Sidekiq	Beanstalkd	delayed_job
Sidekiq uses threads to handle many jobs at the same time in the same process. It does not require Rails but will integrate tightly with Rails 3/4 to make background processing dead simple.	Beanstalks's interface is generic, but was originally designed for reducing the latency of page views in high-volume web applications by running time-consuming tasks asynchronously.	Delayed_job (or DJ) encapsulates the common pattern of asynchronously executing longer tasks in the background. It is a direct extraction from Shopify where the job table is responsible for a multitude of core tasks.
Statistics
GitHub Stars -	GitHub Stars -	GitHub Stars 4.8K
GitHub Forks -	GitHub Forks -	GitHub Forks 952
Stacks 1.2K	Stacks 111	Stacks 53
Followers 632	Followers 161	Followers 65
Votes 408	Votes 74	Votes 6
Pros & Cons
Pros 124 Simple 99 Efficient background processing 60 Scalability 37 Better then resque 26 Great documentation	Pros 23 Fast 12 Does one thing well 12 Free 9 Scalability 8 Simplicity	Pros 3 Easy to get started 2 Reliable 1 Doesn't require Redis

What are some alternatives to Sidekiq, Beanstalkd, delayed_job?

Hangfire

It is an open-source framework that helps you to create, process and manage your background jobs, i.e. operations you don't want to put in your request processing pipeline. It supports all kind of background tasks – short-running and long-running, CPU intensive and I/O intensive, one shot and recurrent.

Resque

Background jobs can be any Ruby class or module that responds to perform. Your existing classes can easily be converted to background jobs or you can create new classes specifically to do work. Or, you can do both.

Faktory

Redis -> Sidekiq == Faktory -> Faktory. Faktory is a server daemon which provides a simple API to produce and consume background jobs. Jobs are a small JSON hash with a few mandatory keys.

Kue

Kue is a feature rich priority job queue for node.js backed by redis. A key feature of Kue is its clean user-interface for viewing and managing queued, active, failed, and completed jobs.

Bull

The fastest, most reliable, Redis-based queue for Node. Carefully written for rock solid stability and atomicity.

Bulk Writer GPT

Create unlimited articles in one go by uploading a CSV of keywords. The system handles queue management, real-time progress tracking, automatic retries for failed articles, and multi-format exports—making large-scale content creation fast, stable, and hands-free.

Cron

Background-only application which launches and runs other applications, or opens documents, at specified dates and times.

PHP-FPM

It is an alternative PHP FastCGI implementation with some additional features useful for sites of any size, especially busier sites. It includes Adaptive process spawning, Advanced process management with graceful stop/start, Emergency restart in case of accidental opcode cache destruction etc.

Que

Que is a high-performance alternative to DelayedJob or QueueClassic that improves the reliability of your application by protecting your jobs with the same ACID guarantees as the rest of your data.

Goose

It is a simple, reliable & scalable background processing library for Clojure. It has a transparent design & cloud-native architecture.

Related Comparisons

Bootstrap vs Materialize

Django vs Laravel vs Node.js

Bootstrap vs Foundation vs Material UI

Node.js vs Spring-Boot

Flyway vs Liquibase

Beanstalkd vs Sidekiq vs delayed_job: What are the differences?

Introduction:

Beanstalkd, Sidekiq, and delayed_job are all popular background processing systems used in web development to handle tasks asynchronously.

Architecture: Beanstalkd is a simple, fast work queue service, while Sidekiq is a Ruby-based background processing system designed to be simple and efficient. On the other hand, delayed_job is a Ruby gem for queueing jobs and deferred execution.
Dependencies: Beanstalkd does not have any dependencies. Sidekiq requires Redis as a backend for job storage and processing. delayed_job relies on Active Record and a database table for storing job information.
Concurrency: Sidekiq's multi-threaded approach allows it to process multiple jobs concurrently using a small number of threads. Beanstalkd, however, relies on multiple worker processes to handle concurrency. delayed_job operates in a single-threaded manner, processing jobs sequentially.
Monitoring: Beanstalkd provides basic monitoring and stats through telnet commands. Sidekiq offers a web interface for monitoring and managing jobs, providing real-time statistics. delayed_job lacks a built-in monitoring tool but can be integrated with external monitoring services.
Error Handling: Sidekiq provides robust error handling and automatic retry mechanisms for failed jobs. Beanstalkd offers basic error logging but lacks built-in retry functionality. delayed_job requires manual intervention for handling errors and retries.
Community Support: Sidekiq has a large and active community, with extensive documentation and support available. Beanstalkd also has a dedicated user base, but may not offer as much support as Sidekiq. delayed_job, being a part of the Rails ecosystem, benefits from the Rails community's support but may not have as much standalone support.

In Summary, Beanstalkd, Sidekiq, and delayed_job each have unique features and characteristics that make them suitable for different types of background processing tasks in web development.