Keycloak vs OneLogin: What are the differences?

Introduction

Keycloak and OneLogin are both identity and access management solutions that provide authentication and authorization services for applications. While they have similar functionalities, there are several key differences between them.

1. Integration: Keycloak offers seamless integration with other Red Hat products and is widely used in the Open Source community, making it an excellent choice for organizations with Red Hat infrastructure. On the other hand, OneLogin provides extensive integration options with various third-party applications and has a vast library of pre-built connectors, making it more suitable for organizations with a diverse application landscape.

2. Pricing: Keycloak is an open-source platform that is free to use, which makes it a cost-effective option for smaller organizations or those on a tight budget. In contrast, OneLogin is a subscription-based service that comes with a licensing fee, making it more suitable for larger enterprises with complex security requirements and the necessary financial resources.

3. User Experience: Keycloak provides a user-friendly and intuitive interface, offering a seamless authentication experience for both end-users and administrators. OneLogin, however, offers a more polished and customizable user interface, allowing organizations to provide a branded and personalized experience for their users.

4. Support and Documentation: Keycloak benefits from an active and supportive Open Source community, offering extensive documentation, forums, and user groups. OneLogin, being a commercial solution, provides dedicated customer support and offers comprehensive documentation, training resources, and professional services to assist organizations with their implementation and ongoing maintenance.

5. Technical Capabilities: Keycloak is built using Java and Java EE technologies, providing robust scalability and extensibility options. OneLogin, on the other hand, is built using Ruby on Rails and offers a wide range of features, such as multi-factor authentication, single sign-on, and adaptive authentication, which can be fully customized based on an organization's specific requirements.

6. Deployment Options: Keycloak can be deployed on-premises or in a cloud environment, giving organizations the flexibility to choose the deployment model that suits their needs. OneLogin, in addition to cloud deployment, also offers an on-premises option for organizations with strict data privacy and security requirements.

In summary, Keycloak offers seamless integration with Red Hat products, is free to use, provides an intuitive user experience, benefits from open-source support, has robust technical capabilities, and offers flexible deployment options. OneLogin, on the other hand, provides extensive integration options, has a licensing fee, offers a polished user experience, provides dedicated customer support, offers advanced features, and supports on-premises deployment.