Emacs vs Gerrit Code Review

Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

Emacs

1.3K
1.2K
+ 1
322
Gerrit Code Review

116
224
+ 1
59
Add tool

Emacs vs Gerrit Code Review: What are the differences?

Introduction: This Markdown code outlines the key differences between Emacs and Gerrit Code Review, highlighting specific aspects that set these two tools apart in the development landscape.

1. Customization and Extensibility: Emacs is highly customizable and extensible through the use of Emacs Lisp, allowing users to tailor the editor to their specific needs by adding new functionalities or modifying existing ones. In contrast, Gerrit Code Review is focused on code review processes and lacks the extensive customization capabilities of Emacs.

2. User Interface: Emacs has a powerful but steep learning curve with its command-driven interface that requires memorizing numerous key bindings for efficient usage. On the other hand, Gerrit Code Review provides a more intuitive web-based interface that simplifies the code review process for users, particularly those who are not well-versed in Emacs commands.

3. Collaboration Features: Gerrit Code Review is specifically designed for collaborative development, offering features like reviewing changesets, commenting on code, and tracking the progress of code reviews. While Emacs also supports collaboration through plugins and integrations, it is primarily an individual productivity tool rather than a dedicated platform for team code reviews.

4. Version Control Integration: Gerrit Code Review integrates seamlessly with Git, providing a tight coupling between the code review process and version control system. Emacs, on the other hand, can be configured to work with various version control systems, but the level of integration may not be as deep as that offered by Gerrit for Git.

5. Workflow Automation: Gerrit Code Review streamlines the code review workflow by automating tasks such as assigning reviewers, setting up approval criteria, and triggering notifications based on predefined rules. In contrast, Emacs relies on the user's manual intervention and customization to manage workflows, lacking the built-in automation capabilities of Gerrit Code Review.

6. Code Review Focus: While Emacs is a versatile text editor with a wide range of features beyond code editing, Gerrit Code Review is purpose-built for code review processes, offering specialized tools and functionalities tailored specifically for reviewing and improving code quality.

In Summary, the key differences between Emacs and Gerrit Code Review lie in customization and extensibility, user interface, collaboration features, version control integration, workflow automation, and code review focus, highlighting varying strengths and focuses in the development tools landscape.

Get Advice from developers at your company using StackShare Enterprise. Sign up for StackShare Enterprise.
Learn More
Pros of Emacs
Pros of Gerrit Code Review
  • 65
    Vast array of extensions
  • 44
    Have all you can imagine
  • 40
    Everything i need in one place
  • 39
    Portability
  • 32
    Customer config
  • 16
    Your config works on any platform
  • 13
    Low memory consumption
  • 11
    Perfect for monsters
  • 10
    All life inside one program
  • 8
    Extendable, portable, fast - all at your fingertips
  • 6
    Enables extremely rapid keyboard-only navigation
  • 5
    Widely-used keybindings (e.g. by bash)
  • 5
    Extensible in Lisp
  • 5
    Runs everywhere important
  • 4
    FOSS Software
  • 4
    Powerful multilanguage IDE
  • 4
    Git integration
  • 4
    May be old but always reliable
  • 3
    Asynchronous
  • 3
    Powerful UI
  • 1
    Huge ecosystem
  • 13
    Code review
  • 11
    Good workflow
  • 10
    Cleaner repository story
  • 9
    Open source
  • 9
    Good integration with Jenkins
  • 5
    Unlimited repo support
  • 2
    Comparison dashboard

Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions

Cons of Emacs
Cons of Gerrit Code Review
  • 4
    So good and extensible, that one can get sidetracked
  • 4
    Hard to learn for beginners
  • 1
    Not default preinstalled in GNU/linux
    Be the first to leave a con

    Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions

    What is Emacs?

    GNU Emacs is an extensible, customizable text editor—and more. At its core is an interpreter for Emacs Lisp, a dialect of the Lisp programming language with extensions to support text editing.

    What is Gerrit Code Review?

    Gerrit is a self-hosted pre-commit code review tool. It serves as a Git hosting server with option to comment incoming changes. It is highly configurable and extensible with default guarding policies, webhooks, project access control and more.

    Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

    What companies use Emacs?
    What companies use Gerrit Code Review?
    See which teams inside your own company are using Emacs or Gerrit Code Review.
    Sign up for StackShare EnterpriseLearn More

    Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions

    What tools integrate with Emacs?
    What tools integrate with Gerrit Code Review?

    Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions

    What are some alternatives to Emacs and Gerrit Code Review?
    Atom
    At GitHub, we're building the text editor we've always wanted. A tool you can customize to do anything, but also use productively on the first day without ever touching a config file. Atom is modern, approachable, and hackable to the core. We can't wait to see what you build with it.
    Eclipse
    Standard Eclipse package suited for Java and plug-in development plus adding new plugins; already includes Git, Marketplace Client, source code and developer documentation. Click here to file a bug against Eclipse Platform.
    Vim
    Vim is an advanced text editor that seeks to provide the power of the de-facto Unix editor 'Vi', with a more complete feature set. Vim is a highly configurable text editor built to enable efficient text editing. It is an improved version of the vi editor distributed with most UNIX systems. Vim is distributed free as charityware.
    Spacemacs
    Since version 0.101.0 and later Spacemacs totally abolishes the frontiers between Vim and Emacs. The user can now choose his/her preferred editing style and enjoy all the Spacemacs features. Even better, it is possible to dynamically switch between the two styles seamlessly which makes it possible for programmers with different styles to do seat pair programming using the same editor.
    Neovim
    Neovim is a project that seeks to aggressively refactor Vim in order to: simplify maintenance and encourage contributions, split the work between multiple developers, enable the implementation of new/modern user interfaces without any modifications to the core source, and improve extensibility with a new plugin architecture.
    See all alternatives