Jenkins X vs OpenShift

Overview

Red Hat OpenShift

Stacks1.6K

Followers1.4K

Votes517

GitHub Stars885

Forks510

Jenkins X

Stacks147

Followers370

Votes16

GitHub Stars4.7K

Forks800

Jenkins X vs OpenShift: What are the differences?

Introduction: In the world of software development, there are various tools and platforms available to streamline the process of Continuous Integration and Continuous Deployment (CI/CD). Two popular options in this space are Jenkins X and OpenShift. While both serve the same purpose, there are key differences between them. Let's explore these differences in detail.

Architecture and Deployment Model: Jenkins X follows a cloud-native architecture and is primarily built for Kubernetes-based infrastructure. It integrates with various cloud providers and utilizes containerization technologies, such as Docker and Kubernetes. On the other hand, OpenShift is a comprehensive enterprise-grade container application platform that provides built-in CI/CD capabilities. It uses a combination of Docker containers, Kubernetes, and Red Hat Enterprise Linux to deliver a platform that supports the entire application lifecycle.
Ease of Use: Jenkins X promotes a GitOps workflow, where the entire CI/CD pipeline is defined and version-controlled in the Git repository. The platform strives to simplify the process of setting up and managing CI/CD pipelines by providing automated project scaffolding, pipeline configuration, and environment provisioning. OpenShift offers ease of use through its web-based interface, allowing developers to easily create and manage applications without getting involved in low-level infrastructure operations.
Native Kubernetes Integration: Jenkins X is specifically designed for Kubernetes and leverages its powerful native features. It automatically provisions and manages ephemeral environments for each pull request and provides preview environments for testing changes before merging. OpenShift also integrates with Kubernetes and provides additional enterprise-focused features on top of it, such as built-in monitoring, logging, and security capabilities.
Community Support and Ecosystem: Jenkins X has a vibrant and active community with continuous contributions to its open-source codebase. It benefits from the wide adoption of Jenkins and Kubernetes, which translates into excellent community support and extensive integration options with other tools and services. OpenShift, being an enterprise-grade platform developed by Red Hat, has a strong backing and a dedicated support network. It offers a comprehensive ecosystem with a wide range of integrated tools and services to streamline the development and deployment process.
Extensibility and Customization: Jenkins X provides an extensible plugin architecture that allows developers to customize and extend its capabilities. It supports a wide range of plugins and integrations with different tools, enabling developers to tailor the CI/CD workflow according to their project requirements. OpenShift also offers extensibility through its rich set of APIs, allowing developers to integrate with custom tools and configure advanced deployment strategies.
Pricing and Licensing: Jenkins X is an open-source project under the Apache License 2.0, which means it is free to use and modify. However, depending on the cloud provider and additional services used, there may be costs associated with infrastructure resources. OpenShift, being a commercial product offered by Red Hat, has licensing costs associated with it. The pricing model varies based on the edition and support package chosen, making it suitable for enterprises looking for comprehensive support and assurance.

In summary, Jenkins X is a cloud-native CI/CD platform specifically designed for Kubernetes-based infrastructure, offering extensibility and strong community support. OpenShift, on the other hand, is an enterprise-grade container application platform that provides built-in CI/CD capabilities and a comprehensive ecosystem. The choice between them depends on factors such as the infrastructure used, the level of enterprise features required, support needs, and licensing considerations.

Share your Stack

Help developers discover the tools you use. Get visibility for your team's tech choices and contribute to the community's knowledge.

View Docs

CLI (Node.js)

Manual

Advice on Red Hat OpenShift, Jenkins X

Stratos

Jan 13, 2020

Needs advice

We are a mid-size startup running Scala apps. Moving from Jenkins/EC2 to Spinnaker/EKS and looking for a tool to cover our CI/CD needs. Our code lives on GitHub, artifacts in nexus, images in ECR.

Drone is out, GitHub actions are being considered along with Circle CI and GitLab CI.

We primarily need:

Fast SBT builds (caching)
Low maintenance overhead (ideally serverless)
Everything as code

Ease of use

181k views181k

Comments

Detailed Comparison

Red Hat OpenShift	Jenkins X
OpenShift is Red Hat's Cloud Computing Platform as a Service (PaaS) offering. OpenShift is an application platform in the cloud where application developers and teams can build, test, deploy, and run their applications.	Jenkins X is a CI/CD solution for modern cloud applications on Kubernetes
Built-in support for Node.js, Ruby, Python, PHP, Perl, and Java (the standard in today's Enterprise);OpenShift is extensible with a customizable cartridge functionality that allows developers to add any other language they wish. We've seen everything from Clojure to Cobol running on OpenShift;OpenShift supports frameworks ranging from Spring, to Rails, to Play;Autoscaling- OpenShift can scale your application by adding additional instances of your application and enabling clustering. Alternatively, you can manually scale the amount of resources with which your application is deployed when needed;OpenShift by Red Hat is built on open-source technologies (Red Hat Enterprise Linux- RHEL);One Click Deployment- Deploying to the OpenShift platform is as easy a clicking a button or entering a "Git push" command	Automated CI and CD - Rather than having to have deep knowledge of the internals of Jenkins Pipeline, Jenkins X will default awesome pipelines for your projects that implements fully CI and CD; Environment Promotion via GitOps - Each team gets a set of Environments. Jenkins X then automates the management of the Environments and the Promotion of new versions of Applications between Environments via GitOps; Pull Request Preview Environments - Jenkins X automatically spins up Preview Environments for your Pull Requests so you can get fast feedback before changes are merged to master; Feedback on Issues and Pull Requests - Jenkins X automatically comments on your Commits, Issues and Pull Requests with feedback as code is ready to be previewed, is promoted to environments or if Pull Requests are generated automatically to upgrade versions
Statistics
GitHub Stars 885	GitHub Stars 4.7K
GitHub Forks 510	GitHub Forks 800
Stacks 1.6K	Stacks 147
Followers 1.4K	Followers 370
Votes 517	Votes 16
Pros & Cons
Pros 99 Good free plan 63 Open Source 47 Easy setup 43 Nodejs support 42 Well documented Cons 2 Decisions are made for you, limiting your options 2 License cost 1 Behind, sometimes severely, the upstreams	Pros 7 Kubernetes integration 5 Scripted Pipelines 4 GitOps Cons 1 Complexity
Integrations
No integrations available	Kubernetes macOS Linux Mint Ubuntu Debian Fedora

What are some alternatives to Red Hat OpenShift, Jenkins X?

Heroku

Heroku is a cloud application platform – a new way of building and deploying web apps. Heroku lets app developers spend 100% of their time on their application code, not managing servers, deployment, ongoing operations, or scaling.

Jenkins

In a nutshell Jenkins CI is the leading open-source continuous integration server. Built with Java, it provides over 300 plugins to support building and testing virtually any project.

Travis CI

Free for open source projects, our CI environment provides multiple runtimes (e.g. Node.js or PHP versions), data stores and so on. Because of this, hosting your project on travis-ci.com means you can effortlessly test your library or applications against multiple runtimes and data stores without even having all of them installed locally.

Codeship

Codeship runs your automated tests and configured deployment when you push to your repository. It takes care of managing and scaling the infrastructure so that you are able to test and release more frequently and get faster feedback for building the product your users need.

Clever Cloud

Clever Cloud is a polyglot cloud application platform. The service helps developers to build applications with many languages and services, with auto-scaling features and a true pay-as-you-go pricing model.

CircleCI

Continuous integration and delivery platform helps software teams rapidly release code with confidence by automating the build, test, and deploy process. Offers a modern software development platform that lets teams ramp.

Google App Engine

Google has a reputation for highly reliable, high performance infrastructure. With App Engine you can take advantage of the 10 years of knowledge Google has in running massively scalable, performance driven systems. App Engine applications are easy to build, easy to maintain, and easy to scale as your traffic and data storage needs grow.

TeamCity

TeamCity is a user-friendly continuous integration (CI) server for professional developers, build engineers, and DevOps. It is trivial to setup and absolutely free for small teams and open source projects.

Drone.io

Drone is a hosted continuous integration service. It enables you to conveniently set up projects to automatically build, test, and deploy as you make changes to your code. Drone integrates seamlessly with Github, Bitbucket and Google Code as well as third party services such as Heroku, Dotcloud, Google AppEngine and more.

wercker

Wercker is a CI/CD developer automation platform designed for Microservices & Container Architecture.

Related Comparisons

Jenkins X vs OpenShift: What are the differences?

Architecture and Deployment Model: Jenkins X follows a cloud-native architecture and is primarily built for Kubernetes-based infrastructure. It integrates with various cloud providers and utilizes containerization technologies, such as Docker and Kubernetes. On the other hand, OpenShift is a comprehensive enterprise-grade container application platform that provides built-in CI/CD capabilities. It uses a combination of Docker containers, Kubernetes, and Red Hat Enterprise Linux to deliver a platform that supports the entire application lifecycle.
Ease of Use: Jenkins X promotes a GitOps workflow, where the entire CI/CD pipeline is defined and version-controlled in the Git repository. The platform strives to simplify the process of setting up and managing CI/CD pipelines by providing automated project scaffolding, pipeline configuration, and environment provisioning. OpenShift offers ease of use through its web-based interface, allowing developers to easily create and manage applications without getting involved in low-level infrastructure operations.
Native Kubernetes Integration: Jenkins X is specifically designed for Kubernetes and leverages its powerful native features. It automatically provisions and manages ephemeral environments for each pull request and provides preview environments for testing changes before merging. OpenShift also integrates with Kubernetes and provides additional enterprise-focused features on top of it, such as built-in monitoring, logging, and security capabilities.
Community Support and Ecosystem: Jenkins X has a vibrant and active community with continuous contributions to its open-source codebase. It benefits from the wide adoption of Jenkins and Kubernetes, which translates into excellent community support and extensive integration options with other tools and services. OpenShift, being an enterprise-grade platform developed by Red Hat, has a strong backing and a dedicated support network. It offers a comprehensive ecosystem with a wide range of integrated tools and services to streamline the development and deployment process.
Extensibility and Customization: Jenkins X provides an extensible plugin architecture that allows developers to customize and extend its capabilities. It supports a wide range of plugins and integrations with different tools, enabling developers to tailor the CI/CD workflow according to their project requirements. OpenShift also offers extensibility through its rich set of APIs, allowing developers to integrate with custom tools and configure advanced deployment strategies.
Pricing and Licensing: Jenkins X is an open-source project under the Apache License 2.0, which means it is free to use and modify. However, depending on the cloud provider and additional services used, there may be costs associated with infrastructure resources. OpenShift, being a commercial product offered by Red Hat, has licensing costs associated with it. The pricing model varies based on the edition and support package chosen, making it suitable for enterprises looking for comprehensive support and assurance.

Jenkins X vs OpenShift

Overview