Komodo IDE vs NetBeans IDE vs PhpStorm

Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

Komodo IDE

32
74
+ 1
21
NetBeans IDE

686
944
+ 1
514
PhpStorm

13.9K
10.8K
+ 1
1.6K

Komodo IDE vs NetBeans IDE vs PhpStorm: What are the differences?

Introduction:

When choosing an Integrated Development Environment (IDE), developers often compare different options available in the market. In this comparison, we will highlight the key differences between Komodo IDE, NetBeans IDE, and PhpStorm.

  1. Language Support: Komodo IDE supports multiple languages, including Python, PHP, Perl, Ruby, and JavaScript. NetBeans IDE has excellent support for Java and other languages like HTML, JavaScript, and PHP but lacks advanced support for Ruby and Python. PhpStorm is primarily designed for PHP development but also has strong support for HTML, CSS, JavaScript, and other web development languages.

  2. Code Refactoring Tools: Komodo IDE offers basic code refactoring tools compared to NetBeans IDE and PhpStorm. NetBeans IDE provides a wide range of powerful code refactoring tools, making it easier for developers to maintain and improve their codebase. PhpStorm is known for its advanced code refactoring capabilities, including Rename, Extract, Inline, and Safe Delete.

  3. Version Control Integration: Komodo IDE has built-in support for popular version control systems like Git, Mercurial, and Subversion. NetBeans IDE also offers seamless integration with Git, Subversion, and Mercurial, providing developers with efficient version control capabilities. PhpStorm has robust version control integration with Git, GitHub, Mercurial, and other systems, allowing developers to manage their projects effectively.

  4. Debugger Features: Komodo IDE comes with a powerful debugger that supports multiple languages, allowing developers to debug code efficiently. NetBeans IDE has an integrated debugger that provides features like breakpoints, watchpoints, and stepping through code. PhpStorm offers an advanced debugger with smart step into, run to cursor, and evaluation inline while debugging for PHP and JavaScript.

  5. User Interface Customization: Komodo IDE offers customizable user interfaces with themes and layouts to suit individual preferences. NetBeans IDE provides a flexible UI with the option to customize toolbars, windows, and editor layouts. PhpStorm allows users to personalize their IDE with custom themes, keymaps, and tool windows, enhancing productivity and user experience.

  6. Community Support and Updates: Komodo IDE has a smaller community compared to NetBeans IDE and PhpStorm, which have active developer communities providing regular updates, plugins, and support. NetBeans IDE is an open-source project with strong community support, ensuring continuous improvements and bug fixes. PhpStorm is a commercial IDE with a dedicated team of developers releasing frequent updates and providing excellent technical support to users.

In Summary, when choosing an IDE, developers should consider factors such as language support, code refactoring tools, version control integration, debugger features, user interface customization, and community support.

Advice on Komodo IDE, NetBeans IDE, and PhpStorm
Johnny Bell

When I switched to Visual Studio Code 12 months ago from PhpStorm I was in love, it was great. However after using VS Code for a year, I see myself switching back and forth between WebStorm and VS Code. The VS Code plugins are great however I notice Prettier, auto importing of components and linking to the definitions often break, and I have to restart VS Code multiple times a week and sometimes a day.

We use Ruby here so I do like that Visual Studio Code highlights that for me out of the box, with WebStorm I'd need to probably also install RubyMine and have 2 IDE's going at the same time.

Should I stick with Visual Studio Code, or switch to something else? #help

See more
Replies (15)
Erik Ostrom
Recommends
on
RubyMineRubyMine

If you're working with both Ruby and JavaScript, buy RubyMine and shut down the other two. It's much better for Ruby than Visual Studio Code is. It can also do everything WebStorm does, if you install the plugins you need from JetBrains, and they all work together nicely.

See more
Marc Swikull
Recommends
on
RubyMineRubyMine

If you install RubyMine, you shouldn't need WebStorm, as all the functionality of WebStorm appears to be included in RubyMine. (See here: https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/a/132950).

I've used PhpStorm for several years and have never needed to open (or even download) WebStorm for anything front-end or JavaScript related.

See more
Russel Werner
Lead Engineer at StackShare · | 6 upvotes · 260.1K views
Recommends
on
WebStormWebStorm
at

I work at the same company as you and I use WebStorm for 99% of my tasks. I also have RubyMine installed and use that when I have to tweak some backend code. I tried using RubyMine for JavaScript but was unhappy with how it felt and I believe that WebStorm is faster because it has less plugins and language extensions running. Summary: Buy and use WebStorm for primary development and keep VS Code around for when you have to touch Ruby.

See more
Recommends
on
Visual Studio CodeVisual Studio Code

I've never had much issue running multiple IDEs and generally pick them based on the languages they best support. For front end work where I mainly use TypeScript, I stick heavily with Visual Studio Code. However, for backend work which we do primarily in Python, PyCharm is my go-to editor. The one thing that I do however is I do remap keyboard shortcuts so I get consistent keyboard ability even when I switch IDEs.

See more
Danny Battison
Recommends
on
PhpStormPhpStorm

JetBrains all the way - my entire team uses PhpStorm and none of us would even consider switching.

The availability of IDEs for other languages along with consistency in environment and keyboard shortcuts is also a godsend, which is the reason I'd also choose Rider over Visual Studio (but also VS for Mac is trash, but I digress...)

See more
Recommends
on
Visual Studio CodeVisual Studio Code

Visual Studio Code is a text editor. And this is best option in my opinion. For Ruby, I cannot say how VS Code is good. If you wanna choose IDE, RubyMine should fit your needs. Because IDEs are more compatible with major needs. But text editors are just text editor. You can do same things with also text editors. I recommend to try both VS Code and RubyMine. And you will be able to find which fits better for your needs

See more
Recommends
on
PhpStormPhpStorm

So here is the deal man, bottom line you want to write code. All of these tools are built in a mouse-driven world, they are designed not for engineers, but office monkeys. If you want a real workflow that gives you ultimate performance, customization and speed you need to use a modal editor, I suggest NeoVim. Start using it 20% of the time on single file edits, watch youtube videos about it and teach yourself vim gestures. It will infuriate you for 6 weeks, make you cry for another 2 months. But as you use it more, as long as your usage goes over 40% of the time, in 6 months you will understand why most of the world's too engineers use it. Settling on lesser editors out of laziness is exactly the attitude that results in shitty the engineering. Yeah it's hard. You're smart. You do hard things. Once it isn't hard anymore you will blow yourself away at how much more efficiently you edit files.

Also vim keybindings in a mouse driven editor does not cut it. Managing files, buffers and workflow is half of the value of vim/neovim. It is OK if you have to use an IDE (currently I only use an IDE for java development, so I have little choice)

So use VSCode while you teach yourself vim.

See more
Recommends
on
Visual Studio CodeVisual Studio Code

If I have to choose one I would go with VS Code; it’s become pretty mature and keeps getting better. If those plugins are creating problems for you then just uninstall them, find an alternative, or make a PR to fix. But at the end of the day these are IDE’s and they are meant to save you time. I would go with whatever helps you develop code faster. If restarting VS code slows you down then make a switch, that personally would annoying the crap out of me. Else maybe it’s a quick restart, not the end of the word, hopefully someone will fix at some point.

See more
Recommends
on
Visual Studio CodeVisual Studio Code

If you find something that works and are comfortable with it, stay with it. Changing IDE's and learning their idiosyncrasies takes valuable time away from programming while learning setups and keyboard short cuts. I personally use VS Code for cost and decent multiple language support. I've had issues occasionally with it locking up, but it is under heavy development and continually improving. I have also found it more intuitive for new programmers. ** Having profiles for different languages can reduce the amount of plugins running and issues they can cause.

See more
Recommends
on
PhpStormPhpStorm

I usually have both running but do the bulk of my language work in the appropriate JetBrains flavor. One thing to watch out for in VS is that under the hood it is running the tools needed for whatever language you are working with. This is where tools like JetBrains shine. While I am sure you can tune the heck out of what you use in VS, the provides context and clarity...

See more
Kyle Schoonover
Senior Software Engineer at Nordstrom · | 2 upvotes · 222.8K views
Recommends
on
Visual Studio CodeVisual Studio Code

I'm personally a Visual Studio Code fan. I've used it for both Go and Java. It really depends on the quality and support of the plugins. Typically VS Code doesn't crash as much as a bad plugin causes an unforeseen error. Make sure you stay up to date and look at alternative plugins.

See more
Lungu Alexandru-Mihai
Recommends
on
VimVim

Well you can try for a while MacVim because it is already configured with tons of plugins. My favourite text editors are Sublime Text and TextMate which are lightweight and speedy. My feeling is that JetBrains IDEs are making you brainless.

See more
Recommends
at

Visiual Studio is the best

See more
Recommends

An integrated development environment software with huge potential in the future is VS Code. So I would personally say you can use VS code.

See more
Recommends
on
Visual Studio CodeVisual Studio Code

Are you using the prettier-vscode VSCode extension or prettier via prettier-eslint? The prettier-vscode extension recommends you...

Use prettier-eslint instead of prettier. Other settings will only be fallbacks in case they could not be inferred from ESLint rules.

See more
Get Advice from developers at your company using StackShare Enterprise. Sign up for StackShare Enterprise.
Learn More
Pros of Komodo IDE
Pros of NetBeans IDE
Pros of PhpStorm
  • 4
    Code Completion
  • 3
    Python Support
  • 3
    12 is now free
  • 3
    Markdown Preview
  • 3
    Crossplatform
  • 1
    Minimap Code Preview
  • 1
    Live preview
  • 1
    VIM Keybindings
  • 1
    Sublime Text Keybindings
  • 1
    Ruby on Rails Support
  • 76
    Rich features
  • 69
    Crossplatform
  • 49
    Plugins(Git, SVN)
  • 38
    Easy to use
  • 38
    Extensible
  • 35
    PHP Support
  • 34
    Java support
  • 28
    File History
  • 21
    Code analysis
  • 18
    MySQL support
  • 14
    Free
  • 14
    Open source
  • 10
    Code completion
  • 9
    Strong Maven Support
  • 8
    NodeJs support
  • 6
    Webdev king
  • 6
    Easy maven project start
  • 6
    Best
  • 4
    Jira Plugin
  • 4
    Foss
  • 3
    Out of the box integration with maven, git, svn
  • 3
    History of changes, friendly tabs
  • 3
    Mandatory
  • 2
    Intuitive ui
  • 2
    Chrome plugin to live update javascript from browser
  • 2
    Groovy support
  • 2
    Native Nette support
  • 2
    I don't like NetBeans
  • 2
    Smarty support
  • 2
    Visual GUI Builder for Swing / AWT
  • 2
    Custom html tags support
  • 1
    Powerful refactoring
  • 1
    Composer commands inside IDE
  • 287
    Best ide for php
  • 232
    Easy to use
  • 218
    Functionality
  • 166
    Plugins
  • 160
    Code analysis
  • 87
    Integrated version control
  • 76
    Great php ide for mac
  • 73
    All-round php ide
  • 62
    Local history
  • 53
    Themes
  • 18
    Best PHP IDE
  • 11
    Database control
  • 10
    Easy to find anything and everything in your code
  • 9
    Best bebugging
  • 9
    Best inspection variable
  • 7
    Command line integration
  • 7
    Great frameworks integration
  • 7
    PHPUnit integration
  • 7
    Getting Better
  • 7
    UX
  • 6
    Composer integration
  • 6
    Performance
  • 6
    Coolest IDE
  • 5
    Real time code validation
  • 5
    Easy to use and github interaction
  • 5
    Neat does the job and easy
  • 5
    Best ide for advanced php and symfony
  • 4
    Best ide for php
  • 4
    TypeScript support
  • 4
    Code indexing
  • 4
    It has no match. it filled one of the biggest void
  • 4
    Fast and relevant auto-complete
  • 4
    Great refactoring support
  • 4
    Cross platform
  • 3
    Integration with Vagrant and Docker
  • 3
    Debugger for Javascript
  • 3
    Good
  • 3
    Very good
  • 2
    Debugging in the Just-In-Time Mode
  • 2
    Perfect locahost / host sync
  • 2
    Awesome debugging features

Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions

Cons of Komodo IDE
Cons of NetBeans IDE
Cons of PhpStorm
    Be the first to leave a con
    • 2
      PHP debug doesn't support conditional breakpoints
    • 14
      Uses a lot of memory
    • 10
      Does not open large files
    • 9
      Slow
    • 8
      Uses Java machine
    • 3
      No way to change syntax highlight for files without ext
    • 2
      No save prompt or asterisk on file change

    Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions

    What is Komodo IDE?

    The professional IDE for major web languages, including Python, PHP, Ruby, Perl, HTML, CSS and JavaScript

    What is NetBeans IDE?

    NetBeans IDE is FREE, open source, and has a worldwide community of users and developers.

    What is PhpStorm?

    PhpStorm is a PHP IDE which keeps up with latest PHP & web languages trends, integrates a variety of modern tools, and brings even more extensibility with support for major PHP frameworks.

    Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

    What companies use Komodo IDE?
    What companies use NetBeans IDE?
    What companies use PhpStorm?

    Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions

    What tools integrate with Komodo IDE?
    What tools integrate with NetBeans IDE?
    What tools integrate with PhpStorm?

    Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions

    What are some alternatives to Komodo IDE, NetBeans IDE, and PhpStorm?
    PyCharm
    PyCharm’s smart code editor provides first-class support for Python, JavaScript, CoffeeScript, TypeScript, CSS, popular template languages and more. Take advantage of language-aware code completion, error detection, and on-the-fly code fixes!
    RubyMine
    JetBrains RubyMine IDE provides a comprehensive Ruby code editor aware of dynamic language specifics and delivers smart coding assistance, intelligent code refactoring and code analysis capabilities.
    Eclipse
    Standard Eclipse package suited for Java and plug-in development plus adding new plugins; already includes Git, Marketplace Client, source code and developer documentation. Click here to file a bug against Eclipse Platform.
    Atom
    At GitHub, we're building the text editor we've always wanted. A tool you can customize to do anything, but also use productively on the first day without ever touching a config file. Atom is modern, approachable, and hackable to the core. We can't wait to see what you build with it.
    Visual Studio Code
    Build and debug modern web and cloud applications. Code is free and available on your favorite platform - Linux, Mac OSX, and Windows.
    See all alternatives