Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Redux vs vuex: What are the differences?
Introduction:
Redux and Vuex are state management libraries commonly used with React and Vue.js frameworks, respectively. While they serve the same purpose of managing application state, there are key differences between the two that make them suited for their respective ecosystems.
Architecture: Redux follows a more structured and rigid architecture, utilizing a single store with a flat hierarchy. On the other hand, Vuex is more flexible in its architecture, allowing for module-based store organization with separate modules for each piece of state.
Development Overhead: Redux is known for its boilerplate code, requiring developers to write more code compared to Vuex due to its patterns like action creators, reducers, and store subscriptions. Vuex, on the other hand, minimizes boilerplate code and provides a simpler, more streamlined development experience.
Mutations vs. Actions: In Vuex, state mutations must be synchronous since it directly mutates the state. Redux, on the other hand, uses actions to describe state mutations, making it asynchronous by nature. This distinction influences how side effects and async operations are handled in each library.
Developer Experience: Vuex is considered more opinionated and provides more out-of-the-box solutions for common scenarios in Vue.js applications. Redux, while offering more flexibility, might require developers to make more decisions and trade-offs in terms of architecture and design.
Community and Ecosystem: Redux has a larger community and ecosystem, with a rich set of tools, libraries, and resources available to aid developers. Meanwhile, Vuex benefits from being tightly integrated with Vue.js, offering seamless integration and enhanced performance optimizations specific to Vue applications.
Learning Curve: Due to its more structured approach and additional concepts like middleware, Redux may have a steeper learning curve for beginners. On the other hand, Vuex's simpler design and closer alignment with Vue.js conventions could make it more approachable for developers new to state management.
In Summary, Redux and Vuex differ in architecture, development overhead, approach to mutations/actions, developer experience, community support, and learning curve, catering to the specific needs and preferences of developers in the React and Vue.js ecosystems.
Pros of Redux
- State is predictable191
- Plays well with React and others150
- State stored in a single object tree126
- Hot reloading out of the box79
- Allows for time travel74
- You can log everything14
- Great tutorial direct from the creator12
- Endorsed by the creator of Flux7
- Test without browser7
- Easy to debug6
- Enforces one-way data flow3
- Granular updates3
- Blabla2
Pros of vuex
- Debugging2
- Zero-config time-travel2
- Centralized State Management2
- Easy to setup1
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Redux
- Lots of boilerplate13
- Verbose6
- Steep learning curve5
- Design5
- Steeper learning curve than RxJs4
- Steeper learning curve than MobX4