Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Appium vs Selenium: What are the differences?
Programming Language Support: One key difference between Appium and Selenium is their programming language support. Appium is designed to support multiple programming languages such as Java, Python, Ruby, and JavaScript, making it more versatile and easier to integrate with a wider range of testing frameworks. On the other hand, Selenium predominantly works with Java, although additional bindings have been developed for other languages like Python and C#. This difference in language support can impact the ease of use for teams with varied technical backgrounds.
Mobile Testing: Another significant difference lies in the primary focus of Appium and Selenium. Appium is primarily designed for mobile app testing, offering robust support for both iOS and Android platforms. It provides specific commands and features dedicated to mobile testing, making it a preferred choice for mobile application testing. Selenium, on the other hand, was initially developed for web application testing and lacks some of the specialized mobile testing features found in Appium.
Native Automation Framework: Appium is an automation framework specifically built for mobile applications, allowing testers to automate native, hybrid, and mobile web applications seamlessly. It leverages vendor-provided automation frameworks (like XCUITest for iOS and UIAutomator for Android) to interact with the mobile elements directly, providing more accurate and efficient testing. Selenium, on the contrary, relies on JavaScript to interact with elements on web applications, which may not offer the same level of precision and reliability for mobile application testing.
Setup and Configuration: The setup and configuration process of Appium and Selenium also differ significantly. Appium requires additional setup steps for mobile testing, such as installing the necessary dependencies, configuring mobile devices, and handling app installations. This complexity can pose a challenge for beginners or teams unfamiliar with mobile testing setups. On the contrary, Selenium typically involves a simpler setup process for web application testing, making it more accessible for a wider range of users.
Access to Device Features: Appium provides direct access to native mobile device features like GPS, camera, and accelerometer, enabling testers to automate scenarios that require interaction with device-specific functionalities. This allows for comprehensive end-to-end testing of mobile applications in real-world conditions. Selenium, being primarily focused on web applications, lacks direct access to such device features, limiting the scope of testing scenarios that can be automated.
Community and Support: The level of community support and resources available for Appium and Selenium also varies. Appium has a dedicated and active community that regularly contributes to its development, provides guidance, and shares best practices for mobile application testing. Selenium, being one of the oldest and widely used automation frameworks for web applications, also enjoys a strong community support base with extensive documentation and resources available online. However, the specific focus on mobile testing in Appium often leads to more tailored support and resources for mobile testers.
In Summary, Appium and Selenium differ in programming language support, focus on mobile testing, native automation framework, setup complexity, device feature access, and community support, making them suitable for different testing requirements.
we are having one web application developed in Reacts.js. in the application, we have only 4 to 5 pages that we need to test. I am having experience in selenium with java. Please suggets which tool I should use. and why ............................ ............................ .............................
with the help of selenium we can automate react js for functional testing
Pros of Appium
- Webdriverio support12
- Java, C#, Python support6
- Open source3
- Great GUI with inspector2
- Active community2
- Support android test automation1
- Internal API access1
- Support iOS test automation1
Pros of Selenium
- Automates browsers177
- Testing154
- Essential tool for running test automation101
- Record-Playback24
- Remote Control24
- Data crawling8
- Supports end to end testing7
- Easy set up6
- Functional testing6
- The Most flexible monitoring system4
- End to End Testing3
- Easy to integrate with build tools3
- Comparing the performance selenium is faster than jasm2
- Record and playback2
- Compatible with Python2
- Easy to scale2
- Integration Tests2
- Integrated into Selenium-Jupiter framework0
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Appium
Cons of Selenium
- Flaky tests8
- Slow as needs to make browser (even with no gui)4
- Update browser drivers2