Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

AWS CodeCommit

Stacks331

Followers825

+ 1

Votes193

BinTray

Stacks51

Followers59

+ 1

Votes24

Add tool

AWS CodeCommit vs BinTray: What are the differences?

AWS CodeCommit: Fully-managed source control service that makes it easy for companies to host secure and highly scalable private Git repositories. CodeCommit eliminates the need to operate your own source control system or worry about scaling its infrastructure. You can use CodeCommit to securely store anything from source code to binaries, and it works seamlessly with your existing Git tools; BinTray: Deploy jar and binary files to a public server. Easy integration with Maven, Gradle, Yum and Apt. Bintray offers developers the fastest way to publish and consume OSS software releases. With Bintray's full self-service platform developers have full control over their published software and how it is distributed to the world.

AWS CodeCommit and BinTray can be categorized as "Code Collaboration & Version Control" tools.

Some of the features offered by AWS CodeCommit are:

Collaboration
Encryption
Access Control

On the other hand, BinTray provides the following key features:

One place for all your Java, Yum and Apt packages
Use smart REST API to retrieve and search for binaries
Easy integration with Maven, Gradle, Yum and Apt

"Free private repos" is the primary reason why developers consider AWS CodeCommit over the competitors, whereas "Free for opensource packages" was stated as the key factor in picking BinTray.

According to the StackShare community, AWS CodeCommit has a broader approval, being mentioned in 25 company stacks & 17 developers stacks; compared to BinTray, which is listed in 4 company stacks and 6 developer stacks.

Advice on AWS CodeCommit and BinTray

Kavita Singh

Dec 15, 2020 | 3 upvotes · 552.3K views

Needs advice

AWS CodeCommit

Bitbucket

and

GitHub

Hi, I need advice. In my project, we are using Bitbucket hosted on-prem, Jenkins, and Jira. Also, we have restrictions not to use any plugins for code review, code quality, code security, etc., with bitbucket. Now we want to migrate to AWS CodeCommit, which would mean that we can use, let's say, Amazon CodeGuru for code reviews and move to AWS CodeBuild and AWS CodePipeline for build automation in the future rather than using Jenkins.

Now I want advice on below.

Is it a good idea to migrate from Bitbucket to AWS Codecommit?
If we want to integrate Jira with AWS Codecommit, then how can we do this? If a developer makes any changes in Jira, then a build should be triggered automatically in AWS and create a Jira ticket if the build fails. So, how can we achieve this?

Replies (1)

Sinisha Mihajlovski

Design Lead | Senior Software Developer · Feb 9, 2021 | 1 upvotes · 364.6K views

Recommends

Hi Kavita. It would be useful to explain in a bit more detail the integration to Jira you would like to achieve. Some of the Jira plugins will work with any git repository, regardless if its github/bitbucket/gitlab.

Manage your open source components, licenses, and vulnerabilities

Learn More

Pros of AWS CodeCommit

Pros of BinTray

44
Free private repos
26
IAM integration
24
Pay-As-You-Go Pricing
20
Amazon feels the most Secure
19
Repo data encrypted at rest
11
I can make repository by myself if I have AWS account
11
Faster deployments when using other AWS services
8
AWS CodePipeline integration
6
Codebuild integration
6
Does not support web hooks yet! :(
4
Cost Effective
2
No Git LFS! Dealbreaker for me
2
Elastic Beanstalk Integration
2
Integrated with AWS Ecosystem
1
Integration via SQS/SNS for events (replaces webhooks)
1
IAM
1
Issue tracker
1
Available in Ireland (Dublin) region
1
CodeDeploy Integration
1
CodeCommit Trigger for an AWS Lambda Function
1
Open source friendly
1
Only US Region
0
Ui

9
Free for opensource packages
6
Easy to use
4
Cool new UI
3
Fast CDN
2
Just because it's great DaaS

Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions

Cons of AWS CodeCommit

Cons of BinTray

12
UI sucks
4
SLOW
3
No Issue Tracker
2
Bad diffing/no blame
2
NO LFS support
2
No fork
2
No webhooks
1
Can't download file from UI
1
Only time based triggers
0
Accident-prone UI

Be the first to leave a con

Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions

What is AWS CodeCommit?

CodeCommit eliminates the need to operate your own source control system or worry about scaling its infrastructure. You can use CodeCommit to securely store anything from source code to binaries, and it works seamlessly with your existing Git tools.

What is BinTray?

Bintray offers developers the fastest way to publish and consume OSS software releases. With Bintray's full self-service platform developers have full control over their published software and how it is distributed to the world.

Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

Jobs that mention AWS CodeCommit and BinTray as a desired skillset

Senior Solutions Architect (Post-Sales) - London or Dublin

LaunchDarkly

- EMEA

View Job Details

+12

Engineering Manager, API Client

Postman

San Francisco, United States

View Job Details

+12

Technical Support Engineer

Postman

Boston/ NYC, United States

View Job Details

+11

See jobs for AWS CodeCommit

See jobs for BinTray

What companies use AWS CodeCommit?

What companies use BinTray?

Manage your open source components, licenses, and vulnerabilities

Learn More

Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions

What tools integrate with AWS CodeCommit?

What tools integrate with BinTray?

Codefresh

Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions

What are some alternatives to AWS CodeCommit and BinTray?

GitHub

GitHub is the best place to share code with friends, co-workers, classmates, and complete strangers. Over three million people use GitHub to build amazing things together.

GitLab

GitLab offers git repository management, code reviews, issue tracking, activity feeds and wikis. Enterprises install GitLab on-premise and connect it with LDAP and Active Directory servers for secure authentication and authorization. A single GitLab server can handle more than 25,000 users but it is also possible to create a high availability setup with multiple active servers.

Bitbucket

Bitbucket gives teams one place to plan projects, collaborate on code, test and deploy, all with free private Git repositories. Teams choose Bitbucket because it has a superior Jira integration, built-in CI/CD, & is free for up to 5 users.

GitHub Enterprise

GitHub Enterprise lets developers use the tools they love across the development process with support for popular IDEs, continuous integration tools, and hundreds of third party apps and services.

SVN (Subversion)

Subversion exists to be universally recognized and adopted as an open-source, centralized version control system characterized by its reliability as a safe haven for valuable data; the simplicity of its model and usage; and its ability to support the needs of a wide variety of users and projects, from individuals to large-scale enterprise operations.

See all alternatives

AWS CodeCommit vs BinTray

Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

Pros of AWS CodeCommit

Pros of BinTray

Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions

Cons of AWS CodeCommit

Cons of BinTray

Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions

What is AWS CodeCommit?

What is BinTray?

Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

What companies use AWS CodeCommit?

What companies use BinTray?

Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions

What tools integrate with AWS CodeCommit?

What tools integrate with BinTray?

Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions

Related Comparisons

Trending Comparisons

Top Comparisons