Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Redis vs etcd: What are the differences?
Redis and etcd are two popular distributed key-value stores. Let's explore the key differences between the two:
Data Model: Redis follows a simple key-value model where the value can be a wide range of data structures like strings, lists, sets, etc. On the other hand, etcd provides a distributed key-value model with very limited data structures, primarily focusing on managing configurations and coordinating distributed systems.
Consistency Guarantees: Redis provides eventual consistency, meaning that updates to the data are not immediately reflected across all instances but eventually propagate. In contrast, etcd offers strong consistency, ensuring that all nodes see the same set of data at any given time.
Scaling: Redis supports horizontal scaling via replication and sharding. It allows for the distribution of data across multiple nodes, improving performance and capacity. Etcd also supports replication and clustering but lacks built-in sharding capability, limiting its scalability compared to Redis.
Data Persistence: Redis offers different persistence options, including both snapshotting and append-only file (AOF) persistence. It allows data to survive restarts or power failures. Etcd, on the other hand, stores data primarily in memory, with an option for periodic snapshots. It is not designed for long-term data persistence and focuses more on real-time coordination.
Cluster Management: Redis does not provide built-in cluster management. It relies on external tools like Redis Cluster or Redis Sentinel for managing distributed deployments. Etcd, being designed as a distributed systems coordination tool, provides built-in cluster management with fault tolerance and leader election capabilities.
APIs and Language Support: Redis offers a rich set of APIs and supports multiple programming languages, making it easy to integrate into various applications. Etcd primarily exposes a simple HTTP(S) API and provides official clients for popular languages like Go, Python, and Java.
In summary, Redis focuses on providing a versatile key-value store and etcd specializes in coordinating distributed systems and managing configurations.
Pros of etcd
- Service discovery11
- Fault tolerant key value store6
- Secure2
- Bundled with coreos2
- Consol integration1
- Privilege Access Management1
- Open Source1
Pros of Redis
- Performance886
- Super fast542
- Ease of use513
- In-memory cache444
- Advanced key-value cache324
- Open source194
- Easy to deploy182
- Stable164
- Free155
- Fast121
- High-Performance42
- High Availability40
- Data Structures35
- Very Scalable32
- Replication24
- Great community22
- Pub/Sub22
- "NoSQL" key-value data store19
- Hashes16
- Sets13
- Sorted Sets11
- NoSQL10
- Lists10
- Async replication9
- BSD licensed9
- Bitmaps8
- Integrates super easy with Sidekiq for Rails background8
- Keys with a limited time-to-live7
- Open Source7
- Lua scripting6
- Strings6
- Awesomeness for Free5
- Hyperloglogs5
- Transactions4
- Outstanding performance4
- Runs server side LUA4
- LRU eviction of keys4
- Feature Rich4
- Written in ANSI C4
- Networked4
- Data structure server3
- Performance & ease of use3
- Dont save data if no subscribers are found2
- Automatic failover2
- Easy to use2
- Temporarily kept on disk2
- Scalable2
- Existing Laravel Integration2
- Channels concept2
- Object [key/value] size each 500 MB2
- Simple2
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of etcd
Cons of Redis
- Cannot query objects directly15
- No secondary indexes for non-numeric data types3
- No WAL1