Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

Formik

333
199
+ 1
0
Material-UI

2.1K
3.6K
+ 1
441
Add tool

Formik vs Material-UI: What are the differences?

Introduction

Formik and Material-UI are two popular libraries used in web development. Formik is a form library for React that simplifies the process of building forms and managing form state. Material-UI, on the other hand, is a set of components that implement the Material Design guidelines for React applications. While both libraries are used in web development, they have some key differences.

  1. Standalone vs Component-based: Formik is a standalone library that focuses on form handling and state management. It provides a higher-order component (HOC) that wraps form components and handles form state. Material-UI, on the other hand, is a component library that provides a set of pre-designed components for building UIs following the Material Design guidelines. It includes form components that can be used alongside Formik to build forms.

  2. Form state management: Formik provides a streamlined way to manage form state by automatically handling form submission, validation, errors, and values. It manages form state internally and provides APIs to access and manipulate the form state. Material-UI, on the other hand, does not directly handle form state management. It focuses on providing UI components and styling. To manage form state with Material-UI, you can integrate it with Formik or use another state management solution like React hooks or Redux.

  3. Customization and Styling: Material-UI provides a wide range of pre-designed components with customizable styles and themes. It follows the Material Design guidelines and provides a consistent and visually appealing UI out-of-the-box. Formik, on the other hand, focuses on form handling and does not provide pre-designed UI components. However, it can be used alongside Material-UI to build custom forms with the desired styling.

  4. Validation: Formik provides built-in validation support with its validation schema and validation function. It allows you to define validation rules for each field and automatically handles validation errors. Material-UI does not provide validation functionality out-of-the-box. You need to implement your own validation logic or use a separate validation library when using Material-UI for forms.

  5. Form submission: Formik provides a streamlined way to handle form submission with its handleSubmit function. It automatically handles form submission and prevents default form behavior. Material-UI does not provide form submission functionality out-of-the-box. You need to implement your own form submission logic using event handlers or integrate Material-UI forms with Formik or other form handling solutions.

  6. Formik-specific features: Formik provides additional features like field array support, form reset, form initialization, form synchronization, and more. It has a rich set of APIs and utilities to handle complex form scenarios. Material-UI does not have these Formik-specific features built-in. If you require these features, you would need to integrate Material-UI forms with Formik or implement them separately.

In summary, Formik is a standalone form library that provides form state management, validation, and submission functionality. Material-UI, on the other hand, is a component library that focuses on providing pre-designed UI components following the Material Design guidelines. While both libraries can be used together, Formik offers more extensive form handling features compared to Material-UI.

Decisions about Formik and Material-UI

Fonts and typography are fun. Material Design is a framework (developed by Google) that basically geeks out on how to assemble your typographical elements together into a design language. If you're into fonts and typography, it's fantastic. It provides a theming engine, reusable components, and can pull different user interfaces together under a common design paradigm. I'd highly recommend looking into Borries Schwesinger's book "The Form Book" if you're going to be working with Material UI or are otherwise new to component design.

https://www.amazon.com/Form-Book-Creating-Printed-Online/dp/0500515085

See more
Get Advice from developers at your company using StackShare Enterprise. Sign up for StackShare Enterprise.
Learn More
Pros of Formik
Pros of Material-UI
    Be the first to leave a pro
    • 141
      React
    • 82
      Material Design
    • 60
      Ui components
    • 30
      CSS framework
    • 25
      Component
    • 14
      Looks great
    • 12
      Responsive
    • 12
      Good documentation
    • 9
      LESS
    • 8
      Ui component
    • 7
      Open source
    • 6
      Code examples
    • 6
      Flexible
    • 5
      JSS
    • 3
      Angular
    • 3
      Very accessible
    • 3
      Fun
    • 3
      Supports old browsers out of the box
    • 2
      Typescript support
    • 2
      # of components
    • 2
      Interface
    • 2
      Designed for Server Side Rendering
    • 1
      Support for multiple styling systems
    • 1
      Css
    • 1
      Easy to work with
    • 1
      Accessibility

    Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions

    Cons of Formik
    Cons of Material-UI
      Be the first to leave a con
      • 34
        Hard to learn. Bad documentation
      • 27
        Hard to customize
      • 20
        Hard to understand Docs
      • 7
        Bad performance
      • 6
        Extra library needed for date/time pickers
      • 6
        For editable table component need to use material-table
      • 1
        Typescript Support
      • 0
        # of components

      Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions

      - No public GitHub repository available -

      What is Formik?

      It takes care of the repetitive and annoying stuff--keeping track of values/errors/visited fields, orchestrating validation, and handling submission--so you don't have to.

      What is Material-UI?

      Material UI is a library of React UI components that implements Google's Material Design.

      Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

      What companies use Formik?
      What companies use Material-UI?
      See which teams inside your own company are using Formik or Material-UI.
      Sign up for StackShare EnterpriseLearn More

      Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions

      What tools integrate with Formik?
      What tools integrate with Material-UI?

      Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions

      What are some alternatives to Formik and Material-UI?
      Redux Form
      It is a Higher Order Component using react-redux to keep form state in a Redux store. It works with React Redux to enable an html form in React to use Redux to store all of its state.
      React Hook Form
      Performant, flexible and extensible forms with easy to use validation.
      Gravity Forms
      It is a WordPress plugin used originally for contact forms, but in a more general sense, it allows site owners to create forms to collect information. It can be used for contact forms, WordPress post creation, calculators, employment applications and more.
      Typeform
      Build beautiful and engaging next-generation online forms, surveys, quizzes, landing pages, and much more with Typeform
      Simple Form
      It aims to be as flexible as possible while helping you with powerful components to create your forms. The basic goal is to not touch your way of defining the layout, letting you find the better design for your eyes.
      See all alternatives