Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Drupal vs Statamic: What are the differences?
Key differences between Drupal and Statamic
Drupal and Statamic are both content management systems (CMS) used to build and manage websites. However, they have some key differences that set them apart:
Coding vs. No Coding: Drupal requires coding skills to create and customize the website. It is built using PHP and requires developers to work with code to make changes. On the other hand, Statamic is a flat-file CMS that allows for easy customization through a user-friendly interface. It does not require any coding skills, making it more accessible for non-technical users.
Database vs. Flat-file Structure: Drupal relies on a traditional database model, where content is stored in a database and retrieved dynamically. This allows for complex relational data structures and advanced content management capabilities. In contrast, Statamic uses a flat-file structure, where content is stored as individual files on the server. This simplifies the setup and deployment process, but may limit the scalability and complexity of the website.
Community and Ecosystem: Drupal has a thriving community of developers and contributors, with a vast ecosystem of modules and themes available. This means that there are many resources and solutions readily available to enhance and extend the functionality of Drupal websites. Statamic, being a newer CMS, has a smaller community and ecosystem, which could limit the availability of plugins and themes.
Content Editing Experience: Drupal provides a flexible and extensive content editing experience, with the ability to create custom content types, fields, and workflows. It offers a wide range of options for content organization and management. Statamic, on the other hand, focuses on simplicity and ease of use. It provides a clean and intuitive content editing interface, but may not offer the same level of flexibility as Drupal.
Scalability and Performance: Drupal is known for its scalability and performance capabilities, making it suitable for large and complex websites with high traffic. It can handle a large number of concurrent users and offers advanced caching and performance optimization features. Statamic, while lightweight and fast, may not be as scalable or performance-oriented as Drupal, especially for websites with heavy traffic or complex functionality requirements.
Cost and Licensing: Drupal is open-source and free to use, making it an attractive option for organizations with limited budgets. However, customization, maintenance, and hosting costs may vary. Statamic, on the other hand, requires a paid license for commercial use, which may add to the overall cost of using the CMS.
In summary, Drupal is a robust and versatile CMS that requires coding skills and offers extensive customization options, while Statamic is a user-friendly CMS that does not require coding and focuses on simplicity. Drupal has a larger community and ecosystem, better scalability and performance capabilities, while Statamic offers a more intuitive content editing experience. The choice between the two depends on the specific needs and expertise of the website owner.
I usually take a slightly different tack because the technical level of people I usually am dealing with is lower. I tend to be pitching to decision makers and not tech people. A bit of my standard answer is below.
Wix and Squarespace are proprietary systems meant for unsophisticated users who want to build their own websites quickly and easily. While they are good for that specific use case, they do not offer any way to move beyond that if your needs arise. Since they are proprietary closed systems if you need something more advanced at some point your only option is to start over.
WordPress is an Open Source CMS that allows much more freedom. It is not quite as simple to setup and create a new site but if you are talking to me then you are not looking to build it yourself so that is really a non-issue. The main benefit of WordPress is freedom. You can host it on virtually any decent web hosting service and since it uses PHP and MySQL you can have virtually any developer take over a project without problem.
I believe in open source because of that freedom. It is good for me as a developer and it is good for my clients. If something were to happen to me or my company you would have no problem finding another qualified WordPress developer to take over the site in a totally seamless fashion. There would be no need to start from scratch.
Additionally the extensible nature of WordPress means that no matter what your future needs, WordPress can handle it. Adding things like e-commerce and custom quoting systems are just two examples of advanced solution's that I have added to WordPress sites years after they were first built.
WordPress is used by tiny one person businesses all the way up to major websites like the NY Times and I think it is right for this project as well.
10 Years ago I have started to check more about the online sphere and I have decided to make a website. There were a few CMS available at that time like WordPress or Joomla that you can use to have your website. At that point, I have decided to use WordPress as it was the easiest and I am glad I have made a good decision. Now WordPress is the most used CMS. Later I have created also a site about WordPress: https://www.wpdoze.com
Pros of Drupal
- Stable, highly functional cms75
- Great community60
- Easy cms to make websites44
- Highly customizable43
- Digital customer experience delivery platform22
- Really powerful17
- Customizable16
- Flexible11
- Good tool for prototyping10
- Enterprise proven over many years when others failed9
- Headless adds even more power/flexibility8
- Open source8
- Each version becomes more intuitive for clients to use7
- Well documented7
- Lego blocks methodology6
- Caching and performance4
- Built on Symfony3
- Powerful3
- Can build anything3
- Views2
- API-based CMS2
Pros of Statamic
- No database6
- Version control your content6
- Surprising flexibility4
- It is based on Laravel4
- Easy templating3
- Great documentation2
- Too expensive for personal blog2
- Self hosting1
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Drupal
- DJango1
- Steep learning curve1
Cons of Statamic
- Not user friendly2