Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
GitHub vs GitLab vs Gitblit: What are the differences?
Introduction
Git is a distributed version control system that allows multiple people to collaborate on a project simultaneously. GitHub, GitLab, and Gitblit are three popular web-based platforms that provide hosting and management services for Git repositories. In this Markdown code, we will explore the key differences between GitHub, GitLab, and Gitblit.
Repository hosting: GitHub is primarily used for hosting open-source projects and has a large community of developers. GitLab, on the other hand, offers both hosted and self-hosted solutions, allowing organizations to have more control over their repositories. Gitblit is a lightweight Git web server that is often used in smaller organizations or teams.
Pricing and licensing: GitHub offers free hosting for public repositories, but charges fees for private repositories and additional features. GitLab, on the other hand, provides a free community edition that can be self-hosted, as well as premium options with additional features. Gitblit is entirely open-source and free to use.
Built-in continuous integration: GitLab has a built-in continuous integration and deployment system, allowing developers to automatically build, test, and deploy their code. GitHub offers a similar service called GitHub Actions, while Gitblit does not have this feature built-in.
Issue tracking and project management: GitLab and GitHub offer advanced issue tracking and project management tools, such as the ability to create and assign tasks, track progress, and automate workflows. Gitblit, being a lightweight web server, does not provide these extensive project management features.
Collaboration features: GitLab and GitHub have built-in features that allow developers to collaborate on code, such as code reviews, pull requests, and inline commenting. These features make it easier for teams to work together and ensure code quality. Gitblit does not provide these collaboration features.
Integrations and extensibility: GitHub has a wide range of integrations and plugins available, allowing developers to integrate their repositories with other tools and services. GitLab also provides a similar level of extensibility and allows integrations with popular project management tools. Gitblit, being a lightweight solution, has limited integration options.
In summary, GitHub is widely used for hosting open-source projects with a strong community, while GitLab offers more control and features for organizations with both self-hosted and hosted options. Gitblit is a lightweight Git web server suitable for smaller teams or organizations.
Pros of Gitblit
- Fast and fulfill just the features I need1
- Better user & group management1
- Free1
- Easy to setup. Runs on OSX1
- Windows authentication is supported0
- Run on Windows0
Pros of GitHub
- Open source friendly1.8K
- Easy source control1.5K
- Nice UI1.3K
- Great for team collaboration1.1K
- Easy setup868
- Issue tracker504
- Great community487
- Remote team collaboration483
- Great way to share449
- Pull request and features planning442
- Just works147
- Integrated in many tools132
- Free Public Repos122
- Github Gists116
- Github pages113
- Easy to find repos83
- Open source62
- Easy to find projects60
- It's free60
- Network effect56
- Extensive API49
- Organizations43
- Branching42
- Developer Profiles34
- Git Powered Wikis32
- Great for collaboration30
- It's fun24
- Clean interface and good integrations23
- Community SDK involvement22
- Learn from others source code20
- Because: Git16
- It integrates directly with Azure14
- Standard in Open Source collab10
- Newsfeed10
- Fast8
- Beautiful user experience8
- It integrates directly with Hipchat8
- Easy to discover new code libraries7
- It's awesome6
- Smooth integration6
- Cloud SCM6
- Nice API6
- Graphs6
- Integrations6
- Hands down best online Git service available5
- Reliable5
- Quick Onboarding5
- CI Integration5
- Remarkable uptime5
- Security options4
- Loved by developers4
- Uses GIT4
- Free HTML hosting4
- Easy to use and collaborate with others4
- Version Control4
- Simple but powerful4
- Unlimited Public Repos at no cost4
- Nice to use3
- IAM3
- Ci3
- Easy deployment via SSH3
- Free private repos2
- Good tools support2
- All in one development service2
- Never dethroned2
- Easy source control and everything is backed up2
- Issues tracker2
- Self Hosted2
- IAM integration2
- Very Easy to Use2
- Easy to use2
- Leads the copycats2
- Free HTML hostings2
- Easy and efficient maintainance of the projects2
- Beautiful2
- Dasf1
- Profound1
Pros of GitLab
- Self hosted508
- Free431
- Has community edition339
- Easy setup242
- Familiar interface240
- Includes many features, including ci137
- Nice UI113
- Good integration with gitlabci84
- Simple setup57
- Has an official mobile app35
- Free private repository34
- Continuous Integration31
- Open source, great ui (like github)23
- Slack Integration18
- Full CI flow15
- Free and unlimited private git repos11
- All in one (Git, CI, Agile..)10
- User, group, and project access management is simple10
- Intuitive UI8
- Built-in CI8
- Full DevOps suite with Git6
- Both public and private Repositories6
- Integrated Docker Registry5
- So easy to use5
- CI5
- Build/pipeline definition alongside code5
- It's powerful source code management tool5
- Dockerized4
- It's fully integrated4
- On-premises4
- Security and Stable4
- Unlimited free repos & collaborators4
- Not Microsoft Owned4
- Excellent4
- Issue system4
- Mattermost Chat client4
- Great for team collaboration3
- Free private repos3
- Because is the best remote host for git repositories3
- Built-in Docker Registry3
- Opensource3
- Low maintenance cost due omnibus-deployment3
- I like the its runners and executors feature3
- Beautiful2
- Groups of groups2
- Multilingual interface2
- Powerful software planning and maintaining tools2
- Review Apps feature2
- Kubernetes integration with GitLab CI2
- One-click install through DigitalOcean2
- Powerful Continuous Integration System2
- It includes everything I need, all packaged with docker2
- The dashboard with deployed environments2
- HipChat intergration2
- Many private repo2
- Kubernetes Integration2
- Published IP list for whitelisting (gl-infra#434)2
- Wounderful2
- Native CI2
- Supports Radius/Ldap & Browser Code Edits1
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Gitblit
- Confusing UI2
- Squash and Merge is not supported0
- No active development0
- No code review functionality0
- No Pull Requests0
Cons of GitHub
- Owned by micrcosoft55
- Expensive for lone developers that want private repos38
- Relatively slow product/feature release cadence15
- API scoping could be better10
- Only 3 collaborators for private repos9
- Limited featureset for issue management4
- Does not have a graph for showing history like git lens3
- GitHub Packages does not support SNAPSHOT versions2
- No multilingual interface1
- Takes a long time to commit1
- Expensive1
Cons of GitLab
- Slow ui performance28
- Introduce breaking bugs every release9
- Insecure (no published IP list for whitelisting)6
- Built-in Docker Registry2
- Review Apps feature1
Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions
What is Gitblit?
What is GitHub?
What is GitLab?
Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
What companies use Gitblit?
What companies use GitLab?
Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions
What tools integrate with Gitblit?
What tools integrate with GitHub?
What tools integrate with GitLab?
Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions
Blog Posts
+11
+3
+2
+12
+7
+17
+32
+12