Buck vs Gradle vs Apache Maven

Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

Buck

27
146
+ 1
8
Gradle

17.2K
9.6K
+ 1
254
Apache Maven

2.8K
1.7K
+ 1
414

Apache Maven vs Buck vs Gradle: What are the differences?

Introduction

Apache Maven, Buck, and Gradle are all build automation tools used in software development. They help in managing and building large-scale projects efficiently. However, there are key differences between them that make each tool unique and suitable for different scenarios.

  1. Dependency Management:

    • Apache Maven: Maven uses a centralized repository for dependency management. It relies on the concept of a Project Object Model (POM), which is an XML file that defines the project structure and dependencies.
    • Buck and Gradle: Both Buck and Gradle allow for more flexible dependency management. They support multiple repositories and provide options to define dependencies using different formats like Maven repositories, local files, or other remote repositories.
  2. Build Performance:

    • Apache Maven: Maven follows a sequential build process, which can be slow for large projects with many modules. Maven builds the project in a top-down approach, which can lead to unnecessary rebuilding of unaffected modules.
    • Buck and Gradle: Both Buck and Gradle offer incremental builds, which significantly improve build performance. They analyze the codebase and only rebuild the necessary components, resulting in faster build times, especially for large-scale projects.
  3. Build Configuration:

    • Apache Maven: Maven works based on conventions and predefined plugins. It requires a specific project structure and relies on predefined lifecycle phases (clean, compile, test, package, etc.) to execute different tasks.
    • Buck and Gradle: Both Buck and Gradle provide more flexibility in build configuration. They support custom scripts and allow for fine-grained control over the build process. This makes them more suitable for complex projects with specific build requirements.
  4. Build Caching:

    • Apache Maven: Maven supports build caching at the dependency level. It checks the local repository for the presence of dependencies and only downloads them if necessary.
    • Buck and Gradle: Both Buck and Gradle offer advanced build caching mechanisms. They cache not only dependencies but also compiled code, resources, and intermediate build artifacts. This significantly reduces build time, especially for incremental builds.
  5. Language Compatibility:

    • Apache Maven: Maven is primarily used for Java projects, although it can also handle other JVM languages like Scala or Groovy.
    • Buck and Gradle: Both Buck and Gradle support a wide range of languages beyond just Java. They provide better support for multi-language projects and have built-in support for popular languages like Kotlin, Swift, Python, and more.
  6. Build Tools Ecosystem:

    • Apache Maven: Maven has been around for a long time and has a large community and ecosystem built around it. It has a vast number of plugins available for various tasks like code quality checks, testing frameworks, packaging options, etc.
    • Buck and Gradle: While Buck and Gradle have smaller ecosystems compared to Maven, they still have a good number of plugins and community support. They are gaining popularity, especially for performance-critical projects or those requiring multi-language support.

In summary, Apache Maven, Buck, and Gradle differ in their dependency management approach, build performance, build configuration flexibility, build caching mechanisms, language compatibility, and the size of their respective ecosystems. The choice between these tools depends on the specific project requirements and priorities.

Get Advice from developers at your company using StackShare Enterprise. Sign up for StackShare Enterprise.
Learn More
Pros of Buck
Pros of Gradle
Pros of Apache Maven
  • 4
    Fast
  • 1
    Java
  • 1
    Facebook
  • 1
    Runs on OSX
  • 1
    Windows Support
  • 110
    Flexibility
  • 51
    Easy to use
  • 47
    Groovy dsl
  • 22
    Slow build time
  • 10
    Crazy memory leaks
  • 8
    Fast incremental builds
  • 5
    Kotlin DSL
  • 1
    Windows Support
  • 138
    Dependency management
  • 70
    Necessary evil
  • 60
    I’d rather code my app, not my build
  • 48
    Publishing packaged artifacts
  • 43
    Convention over configuration
  • 18
    Modularisation
  • 11
    Consistency across builds
  • 6
    Prevents overengineering using scripting
  • 4
    Runs Tests
  • 4
    Lot of cool plugins
  • 3
    Extensible
  • 2
    Hard to customize
  • 2
    Runs on Linux
  • 1
    Runs on OS X
  • 1
    Slow incremental build
  • 1
    Inconsistent buillds
  • 1
    Undeterminisc
  • 1
    Good IDE tooling

Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions

Cons of Buck
Cons of Gradle
Cons of Apache Maven
  • 2
    Lack of Documentation
  • 1
    Learning Curve
  • 8
    Inactionnable documentation
  • 6
    It is just the mess of Ant++
  • 4
    Hard to decide: ten or more ways to achieve one goal
  • 2
    Bad Eclipse tooling
  • 2
    Dependency on groovy
  • 6
    Complex
  • 1
    Inconsistent buillds
  • 0
    Not many plugin-alternatives

Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions

What is Buck?

Buck encourages the creation of small, reusable modules consisting of code and resources, and supports a variety of languages on many platforms.

What is Gradle?

Gradle is a build tool with a focus on build automation and support for multi-language development. If you are building, testing, publishing, and deploying software on any platform, Gradle offers a flexible model that can support the entire development lifecycle from compiling and packaging code to publishing web sites.

What is Apache Maven?

Maven allows a project to build using its project object model (POM) and a set of plugins that are shared by all projects using Maven, providing a uniform build system. Once you familiarize yourself with how one Maven project builds you automatically know how all Maven projects build saving you immense amounts of time when trying to navigate many projects.

Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

What companies use Buck?
What companies use Gradle?
What companies use Apache Maven?

Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions

What tools integrate with Buck?
What tools integrate with Gradle?
What tools integrate with Apache Maven?

Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions

Blog Posts

What are some alternatives to Buck, Gradle, and Apache Maven?
Bazel
Bazel is a build tool that builds code quickly and reliably. It is used to build the majority of Google's software, and thus it has been designed to handle build problems present in Google's development environment.
JavaScript
JavaScript is most known as the scripting language for Web pages, but used in many non-browser environments as well such as node.js or Apache CouchDB. It is a prototype-based, multi-paradigm scripting language that is dynamic,and supports object-oriented, imperative, and functional programming styles.
Git
Git is a free and open source distributed version control system designed to handle everything from small to very large projects with speed and efficiency.
GitHub
GitHub is the best place to share code with friends, co-workers, classmates, and complete strangers. Over three million people use GitHub to build amazing things together.
Python
Python is a general purpose programming language created by Guido Van Rossum. Python is most praised for its elegant syntax and readable code, if you are just beginning your programming career python suits you best.
See all alternatives