CircleCI vs Vault

Overview

CircleCI

Stacks14.5K

Followers7.1K

Votes974

Vault

Stacks816

Followers802

Votes71

GitHub Stars33.4K

Forks4.5K

CircleCI vs Vault: What are the differences?

Introduction: In this comparison, we will analyze the key differences between CircleCI and Vault that cater to different aspects of software development and security management.

Purpose: CircleCI is a continuous integration and continuous deployment (CI/CD) tool that automates the process of building, testing, and deploying software, providing developers with a streamlined workflow. In contrast, Vault is a secret management tool that securely stores and manages sensitive information such as passwords, API keys, and certificates, ensuring their protection.
Functionality: CircleCI primarily focuses on the automation of the software development process by enabling developers to build, test, and deploy code efficiently. On the other hand, Vault emphasizes data security by encrypting and managing sensitive information, offering features like dynamic secret generation and revocation.
User Base: CircleCI is predominantly used by software development teams, including developers, testers, and DevOps engineers, to improve the efficiency and reliability of their software releases. In contrast, Vault is utilized by security professionals and system administrators to strengthen the security posture of an organization through the secure management of secrets.
Integration Capabilities: CircleCI integrates seamlessly with popular version control systems like GitHub and Bitbucket, as well as numerous third-party tools and services to enhance the CI/CD pipeline. Vault, on the other hand, integrates with various cloud providers, databases, and applications to provide a comprehensive solution for secret management and encryption.
Cost Structure: CircleCI offers a pricing model based on the number of concurrent jobs and containers, catering to the scalability needs of different development teams. In contrast, Vault follows a licensing model based on the number of nodes or instances deployed, ensuring that organizations pay based on their usage and deployment requirements.
Focus on Security: While CircleCI focuses on automation and efficiency in software development workflows, Vault prioritizes security and confidentiality by offering robust encryption mechanisms, access controls, and audit logging capabilities to protect sensitive data effectively.

In Summary, CircleCI is oriented towards automating software development processes, whereas Vault specializes in securely managing and protecting sensitive information.

Share your Stack

Help developers discover the tools you use. Get visibility for your team's tech choices and contribute to the community's knowledge.

View Docs

CLI (Node.js)

Manual

Advice on CircleCI, Vault

Dustin

Senior Developer at Elegant Themes

Apr 18, 2019

Reviewon

CircleCI

We use CircleCI because of the better value it provides in its plans. I'm sure we could have used Travis just as easily but we found CircleCI's pricing to be more reasonable. In the two years since we signed up, the service has improved. CircleCI is always innovating and iterating on their platform. We have been very satisfied.

607k views607k

Comments

Somnath

Engineering Leader at Altimetrik Corp.

Jun 25, 2020

Needs adviceon

CircleCI

Drone.io

GitHub Actions

I am in the process of evaluating CircleCI, Drone.io, and GitHub Actions to cover my #CI/ #CD needs. I would appreciate your advice on comparative study w.r.t. attributes like language-Inclusive support, code-base integration, performance, cost, maintenance, support, ease of use, ability to deal with big projects, etc. based on actual industry experience.

Thanks in advance!

1.82M views1.82M

Comments

Felipe

May 24, 2020

Needs advice

My website is brand new and one of the few requirements of testings I had to implement was code coverage. Never though it was so hard to implement using a #docker container.
Given my lack of experience, every attempt I tried on making a simple code coverage test using the 4 combinations of #TravisCI, #CircleCi with #Coveralls, #Codecov I failed. The main problem was I was generating the .coverage file within the docker container and couldn't access it with #TravisCi or #CircleCi, every attempt to solve this problem seems to be very hacky and this was not the kind of complexity I want to introduce to my newborn website.
This problem was solved using a specific action for #GitHubActions, it was a 3 line solution I had to put in my github workflow file and I was able to access the .coverage file from my docker container and get the coverage report with #Codecov.

198k views198k

Comments

Detailed Comparison

CircleCI	Vault
Continuous integration and delivery platform helps software teams rapidly release code with confidence by automating the build, test, and deploy process. Offers a modern software development platform that lets teams ramp.	Vault is a tool for securely accessing secrets. A secret is anything that you want to tightly control access to, such as API keys, passwords, certificates, and more. Vault provides a unified interface to any secret, while providing tight access control and recording a detailed audit log.
Language-Inclusive Support;Custom Environments;Flexible Resource Allocation;SSH Or Local Builds For Easy Debugging;Improved Caching;Unmatched Security;Parallelism;Insights	Secure Secret Storage: Arbitrary key/value secrets can be stored in Vault. Vault encrypts these secrets prior to writing them to persistent storage, so gaining access to the raw storage isn't enough to access your secrets. Vault can write to disk, Consul, and more.;Dynamic Secrets: Vault can generate secrets on-demand for some systems, such as AWS or SQL databases. For example, when an application needs to access an S3 bucket, it asks Vault for credentials, and Vault will generate an AWS keypair with valid permissions on demand. After creating these dynamic secrets, Vault will also automatically revoke them after the lease is up.;Data Encryption: Vault can encrypt and decrypt data without storing it. This allows security teams to define encryption parameters and developers to store encrypted data in a location such as SQL without having to design their own encryption methods.;Leasing and Renewal: All secrets in Vault have a lease associated with it. At the end of the lease, Vault will automatically revoke that secret. Clients are able to renew leases via built-in renew APIs.;Revocation: Vault has built-in support for secret revocation. Vault can revoke not only single secrets, but a tree of secrets, for example all secrets read by a specific user, or all secrets of a particular type. Revocation assists in key rolling as well as locking down systems in the case of an intrusion.
Statistics
GitHub Stars -	GitHub Stars 33.4K
GitHub Forks -	GitHub Forks 4.5K
Stacks 14.5K	Stacks 816
Followers 7.1K	Followers 802
Votes 974	Votes 71
Pros & Cons
Pros 226 Github integration 177 Easy setup 153 Fast builds 94 Competitively priced 74 Slack integration Cons 12 Unstable 6 Scammy pricing structure 0 Aggressive Github permissions	Pros 17 Secure 13 Variety of Secret Backends 11 Very easy to set up and use 8 Dynamic secret generation 5 AuditLog
Integrations
dotCloud GitHub Xcode Azure Container Service Slack Heroku JavaScript Node.js Python Amazon EC2	No integrations available

What are some alternatives to CircleCI, Vault?

Jenkins

In a nutshell Jenkins CI is the leading open-source continuous integration server. Built with Java, it provides over 300 plugins to support building and testing virtually any project.

Travis CI

Free for open source projects, our CI environment provides multiple runtimes (e.g. Node.js or PHP versions), data stores and so on. Because of this, hosting your project on travis-ci.com means you can effortlessly test your library or applications against multiple runtimes and data stores without even having all of them installed locally.

Codeship

Codeship runs your automated tests and configured deployment when you push to your repository. It takes care of managing and scaling the infrastructure so that you are able to test and release more frequently and get faster feedback for building the product your users need.

TeamCity

TeamCity is a user-friendly continuous integration (CI) server for professional developers, build engineers, and DevOps. It is trivial to setup and absolutely free for small teams and open source projects.

Drone.io

Drone is a hosted continuous integration service. It enables you to conveniently set up projects to automatically build, test, and deploy as you make changes to your code. Drone integrates seamlessly with Github, Bitbucket and Google Code as well as third party services such as Heroku, Dotcloud, Google AppEngine and more.

wercker

Wercker is a CI/CD developer automation platform designed for Microservices & Container Architecture.

GoCD

GoCD is an open source continuous delivery server created by ThoughtWorks. GoCD offers business a first-class build and deployment engine for complete control and visibility.

Shippable

Shippable is a SaaS platform that lets you easily add Continuous Integration/Deployment to your Github and BitBucket repositories. It is lightweight, super simple to setup, and runs your builds and tests faster than any other service.

Buildkite

CI and build automation tool that combines the power of your own build infrastructure with the convenience of a managed, centralized web UI. Used by Shopify, Basecamp, Digital Ocean, Venmo, Cochlear, Bugsnag and more.

Snap CI

Snap CI is a cloud-based continuous integration & continuous deployment tool with powerful deployment pipelines. Integrates seamlessly with GitHub and provides fast feedback so you can deploy with ease.

Related Comparisons

Bitbucket vs GitHub vs GitLab

AWS CodeCommit vs Bitbucket vs GitHub

Docker Swarm vs Kubernetes vs Rancher

Grunt vs Webpack vs gulp

Grafana vs Graphite vs Kibana

CircleCI vs Vault: What are the differences?

Introduction: In this comparison, we will analyze the key differences between CircleCI and Vault that cater to different aspects of software development and security management.

Purpose: CircleCI is a continuous integration and continuous deployment (CI/CD) tool that automates the process of building, testing, and deploying software, providing developers with a streamlined workflow. In contrast, Vault is a secret management tool that securely stores and manages sensitive information such as passwords, API keys, and certificates, ensuring their protection.
Functionality: CircleCI primarily focuses on the automation of the software development process by enabling developers to build, test, and deploy code efficiently. On the other hand, Vault emphasizes data security by encrypting and managing sensitive information, offering features like dynamic secret generation and revocation.
User Base: CircleCI is predominantly used by software development teams, including developers, testers, and DevOps engineers, to improve the efficiency and reliability of their software releases. In contrast, Vault is utilized by security professionals and system administrators to strengthen the security posture of an organization through the secure management of secrets.
Integration Capabilities: CircleCI integrates seamlessly with popular version control systems like GitHub and Bitbucket, as well as numerous third-party tools and services to enhance the CI/CD pipeline. Vault, on the other hand, integrates with various cloud providers, databases, and applications to provide a comprehensive solution for secret management and encryption.
Cost Structure: CircleCI offers a pricing model based on the number of concurrent jobs and containers, catering to the scalability needs of different development teams. In contrast, Vault follows a licensing model based on the number of nodes or instances deployed, ensuring that organizations pay based on their usage and deployment requirements.
Focus on Security: While CircleCI focuses on automation and efficiency in software development workflows, Vault prioritizes security and confidentiality by offering robust encryption mechanisms, access controls, and audit logging capabilities to protect sensitive data effectively.

In Summary, CircleCI is oriented towards automating software development processes, whereas Vault specializes in securely managing and protecting sensitive information.