Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Amazon ElastiCache vs Redis: What are the differences?
Amazon ElastiCache and Redis are both widely used caching solutions in the field of cloud computing. Let's explore the key differences between the two:
Managed Service vs. Open-Source Technology: Amazon ElastiCache is a fully managed service provided by Amazon Web Services (AWS), taking care of maintenance, patching, and scaling for you. On the other hand, Redis is an open-source technology that requires self-management, including installation, updates, and server configuration.
Multi-AZ Availability: Amazon ElastiCache offers availability in multiple Availability Zones (AZs), providing built-in redundancy and ensuring high availability in case of a single AZ failure. Redis, on the other hand, does not provide built-in multi-AZ support. To achieve high availability, you need to implement your own clustering and replication mechanisms.
Data Persistence: Amazon ElastiCache allows you to choose between two storage options: Redis, which provides both in-memory and disk-based persistence, and Memcached, which only offers in-memory caching. In contrast, Redis as a standalone technology provides more advanced data persistence features, such as point-in-time snapshots and append-only files, ensuring durability even in case of service restarts or failures.
Data Model and Advanced Features: Redis supports a wide range of data types, including strings, lists, sets, sorted sets, and hashes. It also provides powerful commands and features such as transactions, pub/sub messaging, Lua scripting, and support for geospatial indexes. Amazon ElastiCache also supports these data types and features, making it suitable for applications that require the advanced capabilities of Redis.
Integration with AWS Ecosystem: Amazon ElastiCache seamlessly integrates with other AWS services, such as Amazon EC2, AWS Lambda, and Amazon CloudWatch, allowing you to leverage the full power of the AWS ecosystem. Redis, being an open-source technology, can also be integrated with AWS services, but it requires manual configuration and setup.
Pricing and Cost: Amazon ElastiCache pricing includes costs for infrastructure, maintenance, and support, which can add up depending on the size of your cache cluster. Redis, being an open-source technology, is free to use but requires you to manage the infrastructure yourself. This means that you need to consider the costs of server provisioning, maintenance, and scalability when using Redis in a self-managed environment.
In summary, Amazon ElastiCache provides a fully managed service with built-in multi-AZ support, while Redis offers more advanced data persistence features and a wider range of data types. ElastiCache integrates seamlessly with the AWS ecosystem, whereas Redis requires manual configuration.
Pros of Amazon ElastiCache
- Redis58
- High-performance32
- Backed by amazon26
- Memcached21
- Elastic14
Pros of Redis
- Performance886
- Super fast542
- Ease of use513
- In-memory cache444
- Advanced key-value cache324
- Open source194
- Easy to deploy182
- Stable164
- Free155
- Fast121
- High-Performance42
- High Availability40
- Data Structures35
- Very Scalable32
- Replication24
- Great community22
- Pub/Sub22
- "NoSQL" key-value data store19
- Hashes16
- Sets13
- Sorted Sets11
- NoSQL10
- Lists10
- Async replication9
- BSD licensed9
- Bitmaps8
- Integrates super easy with Sidekiq for Rails background8
- Keys with a limited time-to-live7
- Open Source7
- Lua scripting6
- Strings6
- Awesomeness for Free5
- Hyperloglogs5
- Transactions4
- Outstanding performance4
- Runs server side LUA4
- LRU eviction of keys4
- Feature Rich4
- Written in ANSI C4
- Networked4
- Data structure server3
- Performance & ease of use3
- Dont save data if no subscribers are found2
- Automatic failover2
- Easy to use2
- Temporarily kept on disk2
- Scalable2
- Existing Laravel Integration2
- Channels concept2
- Object [key/value] size each 500 MB2
- Simple2
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Amazon ElastiCache
Cons of Redis
- Cannot query objects directly15
- No secondary indexes for non-numeric data types3
- No WAL1