Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
Azure DevOps vs GitHub Enterprise: What are the differences?
Introduction
In this Markdown code, I will provide the key differences between Azure DevOps and GitHub Enterprise. Both platforms are widely used in the software development industry, but they have distinct features and functionalities that set them apart.
Scalability and Deployment Options: Azure DevOps offers both cloud-based and on-premises deployment options, allowing organizations to choose the option that best suits their needs. On the other hand, GitHub Enterprise is primarily a self-hosted on-premises solution that provides greater control over data privacy and security, making it more suitable for organizations with strict compliance requirements.
Integrated Tools and Capabilities: Azure DevOps provides a comprehensive suite of integrated tools and capabilities for application development, including source control, build and release management, project tracking, and test management. GitHub Enterprise, on the other hand, primarily focuses on source control and collaboration, with additional features like issue tracking, code review, and project management available through third-party integrations.
Community and Collaboration: GitHub Enterprise has a strong community of developers and a social coding platform, making it an ideal choice for open-source projects and collaborative software development. It provides features like pull requests, code reviews, and discussions that foster collaboration among developers. Azure DevOps also supports collaboration but primarily within the organization, with features like code review and team-wide project planning.
Built-in Pipelines and Workflows: Azure DevOps has built-in pipelines and workflows that enable organizations to automate their application development and deployment processes. It provides a visual interface for defining and managing pipelines, making it easier for teams to adopt continuous integration and continuous delivery (CI/CD) practices. GitHub Enterprise, on the other hand, relies on third-party tools like Jenkins for implementing CI/CD pipelines.
Azure Integration and Development Ecosystem: Azure DevOps seamlessly integrates with other Microsoft Azure services, allowing organizations to leverage the full capabilities of the Azure ecosystem for their development projects. It provides native integration with Azure Boards, Azure Repos, and Azure Pipelines, enabling a more streamlined development experience. GitHub Enterprise, on the other hand, is not as tightly integrated with Azure services, although it does provide integrations with other popular cloud platforms and tools.
Pricing and Licensing: Azure DevOps offers a flexible pricing structure that allows organizations to pay for only the services they need, with options for free and paid plans. Pricing is based on the number of users and the selected features. GitHub Enterprise, on the other hand, follows a per-user licensing model, with pricing based on the number of users and the type of deployment (cloud-based or self-hosted).
In Summary, Azure DevOps and GitHub Enterprise differ in terms of deployment options, integrated tools, community collaboration, built-in pipelines, integration with the Azure ecosystem, and pricing/licensing models. Each platform has its strengths and target audience, so organizations need to evaluate their specific requirements and priorities before choosing the most suitable option for their development projects.
Pros of Azure DevOps
- Complete and powerful56
- Huge extension ecosystem32
- Azure integration27
- Flexible and powerful26
- One Stop Shop For Build server, Project Mgt, CDCI26
- Everything I need. Simple and intuitive UI15
- Support Open Source13
- Integrations8
- GitHub Integration7
- Cost free for Stakeholders6
- One 4 all6
- Crap6
- Project Mgmt Features6
- Runs in the cloud5
- Agent On-Premise(Linux - Windows)3
- Aws integration2
- Link Test Cases to Stories2
- Jenkins Integration2
- GCP Integration1
Pros of GitHub Enterprise
- Expensive - $$$4
- Code security2
- CDCI with Github Actions2
- Both Cloud and Enterprise Server Versions available1
- Draft Pull Request1
- User experience0
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of Azure DevOps
- Still dependant on C# for agents8
- Half Baked5
- Many in devops disregard MS altogether5
- Not a requirements management tool4
- Jack of all trades, master of none4
- Capacity across cross functional teams not visibile4
- Poor Jenkins integration3
- Tedious for test plan/case creation2
- Switching accounts is impossible1
Cons of GitHub Enterprise
- $$$2