Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!
PagerDuty vs Sentry: What are the differences?
- Integration and Focus: While both PagerDuty and Sentry are incident management tools, they have distinct focuses and integrations. PagerDuty is primarily focused on managing and resolving incidents in real-time, providing comprehensive coverage for IT alerts, and integrating with various monitoring and alerting tools. On the other hand, Sentry specializes in monitoring and error tracking for software applications, focusing on capturing and diagnosing errors and exceptions in production code.
- Alerting and Escalation: PagerDuty offers robust alerting and escalation capabilities, allowing teams to define on-call schedules, intelligent routing rules, and multiple notification channels to ensure timely incident response. Sentry, however, mainly focuses on capturing and monitoring errors and exceptions as they occur, providing real-time notifications and detailed error reports to developers for debugging and resolution.
- Workflow and Collaboration: PagerDuty provides extensive workflow and collaboration features, enabling teams to triage, manage, and collaborate on incidents effectively. It offers incident timelines, status updates, and centralized documentation to ensure coordinated incident response. In contrast, Sentry is primarily designed for individual developers, providing tools for tracking, investigating, and resolving issues in their code. While it offers some collaboration features, such as assigning issues and commenting, its focus is more on aiding individual developers rather than facilitating team collaboration.
- Monitoring vs. Error Tracking: PagerDuty is built to monitor and manage a wide range of IT infrastructure, including network devices, servers, applications, and cloud services. It integrates with various monitoring tools and provides a centralized platform for incident management. Sentry, on the other hand, is specifically designed for error tracking in software applications. It captures errors and exceptions from code, provides detailed stack traces, and offers insights into the root causes of issues.
- Customization and Extensibility: With PagerDuty, teams can customize their incident management workflows, on-call schedules, escalation policies, and integration with third-party tools. It offers a flexible API and webhook integrations for extending its capabilities. Sentry, while not as focused on customization, provides flexibility in configuring error monitoring and alerting preferences. It also offers integrations with popular development tools and platforms like GitHub, Jira, and Slack.
- Cost and Pricing Model: The cost and pricing models for PagerDuty and Sentry differ. PagerDuty typically offers pricing based on the number of users, services, and integrations required. Its pricing may increase with the number of incidents or notifications generated. In contrast, Sentry offers different pricing plans based on the number of events captured and stored, providing options for both individual developers and enterprise teams.
In Summary, PagerDuty and Sentry have key differences in integration and focus, alerting and escalation capabilities, workflow and collaboration features, monitoring vs. error tracking functionalities, customization and extensibility options, as well as cost and pricing models. Their distinct strengths make them suitable for different incident management and error tracking needs.
I'm currently on PagerDuty, but I'm about to add enough users to go out of the starter tier, which will dramatically increase my license cost. PagerDuty is, in my experience, quite clunky, and I'm looking for alternatives. Squadcast is one I've found, and another is xMatters. Between the three, I'm currently leaning towards xMatters, but I'd like to know what people suggest.
Disclosure I work at Splunk and VictorOps is a Splunk product. But I would suggest in addition to trying the others adding VO to your list. It's important to note that some of the tools are designed as Incident Response tools, others started as mass notification tools. For on-call stick to those designed for incident response.
I would say to use Squadcast, the configuration is easy, provides a lot of features such as war room, RCA tracking postmortem, RBAC and they are quick to add features on request as well, recently I asked for custom on call reminders and I am sure they will add it really soon.
I essentially inherited a Shopify theme that was originally created by an agency. After discovering a number of errors being thrown in the Dev Console just by scrolling through the website, I needed more visibility over any errors happening in the field. Having used both Sentry and TrackJS, I always got lost in the TrackJS interface, so I felt more comfortable introducing Sentry. The Sentry free tier is also very generous, although it turns out the theme threw over 15k errors in less than a week.
I highly recommend setting up error tracking from day one. Theoretically, you should never need to upgrade from the free tier if you're keeping on top of the errors...
Pros of PagerDuty
- Just works55
- Easy configuration23
- Awesome alerting hub14
- Fantastic Alert aggregation and on call management11
- User-customizable alerting modes9
- Awesome tool for alerting and monitoring. Love it4
- Most reliable out of the three and it isn't even close3
Pros of Sentry
- Consolidates similar errors and makes resolution easy238
- Email Notifications121
- Open source108
- Slack integration84
- Github integration71
- Easy49
- User-friendly interface44
- The most important tool we use in production28
- Hipchat integration18
- Heroku Integration17
- Good documentation15
- Free tier14
- Self-hosted11
- Easy setup9
- Realiable7
- Provides context, and great stack trace6
- Feedback form on error pages4
- Love it baby4
- Gitlab integration3
- Filter by custom tags3
- Super user friendly3
- Captures local variables at each frame in backtraces3
- Easy Integration3
- Performance measurements1
Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions
Cons of PagerDuty
- Expensive7
- Ugly UI3
Cons of Sentry
- Confusing UI12
- Bundle size4