Amplitude vs Mixpanel vs Segment

Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

Amplitude

892
697
+ 1
36
Mixpanel

7.1K
3.7K
+ 1
438
Segment

3.1K
937
+ 1
275

Amplitude vs Mixpanel vs Segment: What are the differences?

Introduction

Amplitude, Mixpanel, and Segment are three popular analytics tools used by companies to track and analyze user behavior. While all three tools provide valuable insights, there are several key differences between them.

  1. Data Collection: Amplitude, Mixpanel, and Segment differ in their approach to data collection. Amplitude and Mixpanel require implementation of their respective SDKs to track user events and send data to their servers. On the other hand, Segment acts as a data middleware, allowing users to instrument their app or website just once and then send data to multiple analytics providers, including Amplitude and Mixpanel, without requiring any additional code implementation.

  2. Event-Based Tracking vs. Page Tracking: Amplitude and Mixpanel focus primarily on event-based tracking, where specific actions performed by users are tracked. They allow custom event creation and tracking to gain insights into user behavior. In contrast, Segment offers page tracking as its primary tracking method. It automatically tracks page loads and identifies individual users, allowing for easier analysis of user journeys on websites.

  3. Data Schema: Amplitude and Mixpanel have a defined data schema and require pre-implementation planning to ensure consistent event tracking. Each event and its properties need to be specified upfront to ensure accurate analysis. In contrast, Segment does not require a predefined schema. It can accept and forward data with varying formats and schemas, making it more flexible for ad-hoc tracking.

  4. Analytics Capabilities: Amplitude and Mixpanel provide advanced analytics features, such as funnel analysis, user segmentation, cohort analysis, and A/B testing. These tools offer powerful querying capabilities and visualizations to uncover deeper insights. Segment, on the other hand, provides basic analytics capabilities as it primarily focuses on data collection and sending data to other analytics tools.

  5. Data Processing and Storage: Amplitude and Mixpanel handle the entire data processing and storage infrastructure, allowing users to focus on analysis. They provide powerful analytics databases for quick querying and storage capabilities to retain large volumes of event data. In contrast, Segment acts as a data relay, forwarding the collected data to multiple analytics providers. The actual data processing and storage depend on the chosen analytics tool within the Segment ecosystem.

  6. Cost Structure: Amplitude and Mixpanel have subscription-based pricing models that are usually based on the number of monthly tracked users and the desired feature set. The cost increases as the user base grows. Segment, in addition to its free tier, offers a pricing model based on the number of data events processed per month across all integrated analytics providers. This can be more cost-effective for companies that use multiple analytics tools.

In summary, Amplitude, Mixpanel, and Segment differ in their approach to data collection, tracking methods, schema requirements, analytics capabilities, data processing, storage infrastructure, and cost structure.

Advice on Amplitude, Mixpanel, and Segment
Iva Obrovac
Product Marketing Manager at Martian & Machine · | 8 upvotes · 86.3K views

Hi,

This is a question for best practice regarding Segment and Google Tag Manager. I would love to use Segment and GTM together when we need to implement a lot of additional tools, such as Amplitude, Appsfyler, or any other engagement tool since we can send event data without additional SDK implementation, etc.

So, my question is, if you use Segment and Google Tag Manager, how did you define what you will push through Segment and what will you push through Google Tag Manager? For example, when implementing a Facebook Pixel or any other 3rd party marketing tag?

From my point of view, implementing marketing pixels should stay in GTM because of the tag/trigger control.

If you are using Segment and GTM together, I would love to learn more about your best practice.

Thanks!

See more
Replies (1)
Ruben Lozano
Growth Marketing Specialist at Ruben Lozano Me · | 4 upvotes · 3.1K views

Hello Iva,

I think it is a good exercise to think about this framework once you start to add tags, triggers, and parameters and connect data between different tools (Amplitude, Google Ads, Linkedin Ads, Twitter Ads). I really love a post where Daniel Wolchonok shared a video about the Data Stack at Reforge (https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:6963174688554414080/). My suggestion and what I see in other startups, centralise everything in one platform, Segment, and then send data whatever you need. Allow Google Tag Manager to be the tool for marketers and don't allow them to use Segment (I am a marketer). It is good that marketers have the freedom to set up tags and triggers for conversions and audiences but it is good that they don't have access to everything. So, I found it very simple to do it that way, Segment for everything and then connect Segment with Google Tag Manager where Google Tag Manager will allow marketers to work on the events, conversions, tracking, pixels, etc.

I hope you find this helpful. I will try to work on creating basic documentation to collect all of that information. I found really interesting for many startups at the beginning.

Cheers,

See more
Ben Miller
Chief Product Officer at goLance · | 8 upvotes · 104.2K views
Needs advice
on
AmplitudeAmplitudeMixpanelMixpanel
and
SegmentSegment

I am trying to decide on a solution to better track our user data. We need to track which google ads are leading to signups, and which signups are performing various actions on the site. We then need to visualize this data in various ways. We also need to run A/B tests on features and content, to track which ones lead to the most paid conversions.

See more
Replies (3)
Max Musing
Founder & CEO at BaseDash · | 8 upvotes · 369.3K views
Recommends
on
AmplitudeAmplitude
at

Functionally, Amplitude and Mixpanel are incredibly similar. They both offer almost all the same functionality around tracking and visualizing user actions for analytics. You can track A/B test results in both. We ended up going with Amplitude at BaseDash because it has a more generous free tier for our uses (10 million actions per month, versus Mixpanel's 1000 monthly tracked users).

Segment isn't meant to compete with these tools, but instead acts as an API to send actions to them, and other analytics tools. If you're just sending event data to one of these tools, you probably don't need Segment. If you're using other analytics tools like Google Analytics and FullStory, Segment makes it easy to send events to all your tools at once.

See more
Tony Simonovsky

Another option you might consider is Google Analytics App+Web.

It is a new type of Google Analytics property which is event-based (like Amplitude and Mixpanel). In App+Web you can collect exactly the same data and in the same format as the other 2 tools mentioned.

The great things about it are: - it is free - there is a free integration with BigQuery (though you'll need to pay for BigQuery, but for most SmB's it is peanuts - $5-30 a month)

Not so great: - reporting side is pretty buggy (App+Web is very new).

So if you are ok building your reporting in something like Google Data Studio, App+Web will be a great option. Your data analyst will especially be happy to have all the data in SQL format (BigQuery).

If you choose App+Web, then you can use Google Optimize (also free) as an A/B testing solution.

See more
Ruben Lozano
Growth Marketing Specialist at Ruben Lozano Me · | 4 upvotes · 47.3K views
Recommends
on
AmplitudeAmplitudeVWOVWO

Hello Ben,

I have been using Mixpanel and Amplitude and both of them are good solutions in order to track events on your product; events, funnel analysis, retention and so on. The most important thing is that you set up properly the taxonomy and naming convention of your events' structure. I don't have anything against Segment I tried once but I didn't work with that tool but it for sure is a good one based on other workmates' opinions. ¡Important! When tracking distribution channels, take into consideration the attribution channel and all the touches that the users do in all the channels before your conversions. Some of them are good to open a path and other ones good to close.

Besides that, for A/B testing there are several options in the market but VWO is a good one that with a lot of features to get good insights into the A/B testing. Another one could be Optimizely or Google Optimize. ¡Important! Some teams instead run A/B testing because sometimes that could be a technological issue, they run cohort tests, where basically they change features on the product and they analyse this performance with the new users and compare. That could have another issue like seasonality but it is another option.

Overview, I recommend Amplitude and VWO but just to make simple the answer, because Mixpanel, Segment and the other options that the other users wrote here are good too.

All the best, and let me know how your experience was with all these tools. :)

Cheers,

See more
Manage your open source components, licenses, and vulnerabilities
Learn More
Pros of Amplitude
Pros of Mixpanel
Pros of Segment
  • 11
    Great for product managers
  • 8
    Easy setup
  • 6
    Efficient analysis
  • 2
    Behavioral cohorts
  • 2
    Event streams for individual users
  • 2
    Chart edits get their own URLs
  • 2
    Free for up to 10M user actions per month
  • 1
    Fast
  • 1
    Great UI
  • 1
    Engagement Matrix is super helpful
  • 144
    Great visualization ui
  • 108
    Easy integration
  • 78
    Great funnel funcionality
  • 58
    Free
  • 22
    A wide range of tools
  • 15
    Powerful Graph Search
  • 11
    Responsive Customer Support
  • 2
    Nice reporting
  • 86
    Easy to scale and maintain 3rd party services
  • 49
    One API
  • 39
    Simple
  • 25
    Multiple integrations
  • 19
    Cleanest API
  • 10
    Easy
  • 9
    Free
  • 8
    Mixpanel Integration
  • 7
    Segment SQL
  • 6
    Flexible
  • 4
    Google Analytics Integration
  • 2
    Salesforce Integration
  • 2
    SQL Access
  • 2
    Clean Integration with Application
  • 1
    Own all your tracking data
  • 1
    Quick setup
  • 1
    Clearbit integration
  • 1
    Beautiful UI
  • 1
    Integrates with Apptimize
  • 1
    Escort
  • 1
    Woopra Integration

Sign up to add or upvote prosMake informed product decisions

Cons of Amplitude
Cons of Mixpanel
Cons of Segment
  • 4
    Super expensive once you're past the free plan
  • 2
    Messaging (notification, email) features are weak
  • 2
    Paid plans can get expensive
  • 1
    Limited dashboard capabilities
  • 2
    Not clear which events/options are integration-specific
  • 1
    Limitations with integration-specific configurations
  • 1
    Client-side events are separated from server-side

Sign up to add or upvote consMake informed product decisions

What is Amplitude?

Amplitude provides scalable mobile analytics that helps companies leverage data to create explosive user growth. Anyone in the company can use Amplitude to pinpoint the most valuable behavioral patterns within hours.

What is Mixpanel?

Mixpanel helps companies build better products through data. With our powerful, self-serve product analytics solution, teams can easily analyze how and why people engage, convert, and retain to improve their user experience.

What is Segment?

Segment is a single hub for customer data. Collect your data in one place, then send it to more than 100 third-party tools, internal systems, or Amazon Redshift with the flip of a switch.

Need advice about which tool to choose?Ask the StackShare community!

What companies use Amplitude?
What companies use Mixpanel?
What companies use Segment?

Sign up to get full access to all the companiesMake informed product decisions

What tools integrate with Amplitude?
What tools integrate with Mixpanel?
What tools integrate with Segment?

Sign up to get full access to all the tool integrationsMake informed product decisions

Blog Posts

GitHubOptimizelySegment+3
2
1206
Aug 28 2019 at 3:10AM

Segment

PythonJavaAmazon S3+16
7
2630
Jul 2 2019 at 9:34PM

Segment

Google AnalyticsAmazon S3New Relic+25
10
6891
GitGitHubDocker+34
29
42709
GitGitHubSlack+30
27
18707
What are some alternatives to Amplitude, Mixpanel, and Segment?
Google Analytics
Google Analytics lets you measure your advertising ROI as well as track your Flash, video, and social networking sites and applications.
Google Tag Manager
Tag Manager gives you the ability to add and update your own tags for conversion tracking, site analytics, remarketing, and more. There are nearly endless ways to track user behavior across your sites and apps, and the intuitive design lets you change tags whenever you want.
Optimizely
Optimizely is the market leader in digital experience optimization, helping digital leaders and Fortune 100 companies alike optimize their digital products, commerce, and campaigns with a fully featured experimentation platform.
Crazy Egg
Crazy Egg gives you the competitive advantage to improve your website in a heartbeat without the high costs.
Quantcast
It is a digital marketing company that provides free audience demographics measurement and delivers real-time advertising.
See all alternatives